Peer coaching is a collaborative process where colleagues support each other's professional development through structured interaction, feedback, and reflection. In the workplace, effective peer coaching creates an environment of continuous learning where team members help each other develop skills, overcome challenges, and achieve goals through non-hierarchical relationships built on trust and mutual respect.

For organizations seeking to build a culture of continuous improvement and learning, identifying candidates with strong peer coaching abilities is essential. These individuals become catalysts for team growth, foster knowledge sharing across departments, and help create resilient, adaptable workforces. The best peer coaches balance empathy with accountability, listen actively, communicate effectively, and demonstrate genuine interest in others' development.

When evaluating candidates for peer coaching competency, interviewers should look beyond technical expertise to assess emotional intelligence, communication style, and relationship-building capabilities. Behavioral interview questions focused on collaboration, feedback exchange, and supporting others' growth can reveal a candidate's natural inclination and ability to engage in effective peer coaching relationships. Strong candidates will demonstrate self-awareness about their own development journey while showing a genuine commitment to helping others succeed.

Interview Questions

Tell me about a time when you helped a colleague improve their performance or develop a new skill through informal coaching. What approach did you take?

Areas to Cover:

• The specific situation and why coaching was needed
• The coaching approach/methodology they used
• How they built trust with their colleague
• Specific techniques or frameworks they employed
• How they measured success or progress
• Challenges encountered during the coaching process
• How they adapted their approach based on the colleague's needs

Follow-Up Questions:

• What made you decide to help this particular colleague?
• How did you ensure your coaching was received well and not seen as criticism?
• How did you balance being supportive while still challenging your colleague to improve?
• How has this experience shaped your approach to peer coaching since then?

Describe a situation where you received valuable coaching from a peer. What made this coaching effective, and how did you implement their guidance?

Areas to Cover:

• The context and specific challenge they were facing
• Their openness to receiving feedback or guidance
• The peer's coaching approach and what made it effective
• How they processed and implemented the coaching
• Measurable outcomes from applying the coaching
• What they learned about being a good coaching recipient
• How this experience influenced their own coaching style

Follow-Up Questions:

• What made you receptive to this person's coaching when you might have resisted others?
• How did you overcome any defensive reactions you might have had?
• What specific actions did you take to implement their guidance?
• How has this experience changed how you approach receiving feedback?

Tell me about a time when you had to provide difficult or constructive feedback to a peer. How did you approach this conversation, and what was the outcome?

Areas to Cover:

• The specific situation requiring constructive feedback
• Their preparation process before the conversation
• The communication techniques they employed
• How they managed emotions (both theirs and their peer's)
• The peer's reaction and how they handled it
• Follow-up actions taken after the conversation
• The ultimate impact on the relationship and performance

Follow-Up Questions:

• How did you decide on the right time and place for this conversation?
• What specific language or framework did you use to deliver the feedback?
• How did you ensure the feedback was specific and actionable?
• What would you do differently if you had to have this conversation again?

Describe a situation where you collaborated with a teammate who had a very different working style than yours. How did you approach coaching each other through these differences?

Areas to Cover:

• The nature of the working style differences
• Initial challenges or tensions experienced
• Recognition of different strengths and approaches
• Specific techniques used to bridge the gap
• Mutual learning and adaptation that occurred
• How they formalized or structured the peer coaching
• Long-term impact on their working relationship

Follow-Up Questions:

• How did you identify the root causes of your different working styles?
• What specific compromises or adaptations did each of you make?
• How did you ensure ongoing communication about what was and wasn't working?
• What did you learn about your own working style through this experience?

Tell me about an experience where you established a peer coaching relationship that lasted over time. What made it successful and sustainable?

Areas to Cover:

• How the peer coaching relationship was initiated
• Structure or cadence they established
• Ground rules or expectations they set
• How they maintained momentum and engagement
• Methods for tracking progress or success
• Challenges faced in sustaining the relationship
• Key factors that made the relationship valuable

Follow-Up Questions:

• How did you ensure the coaching relationship remained a priority when work got busy?
• What techniques did you use to keep the relationship fresh and valuable over time?
• How did the focus or nature of your coaching evolve as the relationship matured?
• What did you learn about creating sustainable coaching partnerships?

Describe a situation where you helped a peer overcome a significant challenge or obstacle. What coaching techniques did you employ?

Areas to Cover:

• The specific challenge the peer was facing
• How they assessed what kind of support was needed
• The balance between guidance and empowerment
• Specific questioning techniques they used
• How they helped their peer develop their own solutions
• Follow-up and accountability mechanisms
• Signs of progress or breakthrough moments

Follow-Up Questions:

• How did you differentiate between when to offer direct advice versus when to use coaching questions?
• What indicators did you look for to determine if your approach was working?
• How did you handle moments when your peer felt stuck or discouraged?
• What did you learn about effective coaching from this experience?

Tell me about a time when peer coaching didn't go as planned. What challenges did you face, and what did you learn from this experience?

Areas to Cover:

• The specific situation and initial coaching approach
• Signs that the coaching wasn't working effectively
• Analysis of what went wrong and why
• How they attempted to address the challenges
• Their reflection process and key insights gained
• Changes they've made to their coaching approach
• How they would handle a similar situation today

Follow-Up Questions:

• When did you first realize the coaching wasn't working as expected?
• What specific adjustments did you try to make along the way?
• How did this experience affect your confidence as a coach?
• What would you do differently if you could go back to that situation?

Describe your approach to helping teammates develop self-awareness about their strengths and areas for improvement.

Areas to Cover:

• Their philosophy or framework for developing self-awareness
• Specific techniques they use to promote reflection
• How they balance affirmation with constructive feedback
• Methods for helping others recognize patterns in their behavior
• Tools or resources they recommend or utilize
• How they personalize their approach based on the individual
• Examples of successful outcomes from their approach

Follow-Up Questions:

• How do you approach someone who seems to lack self-awareness about a particular issue?
• What questions have you found most effective for promoting self-reflection?
• How do you help someone understand the impact of their behavior on others?
• How do you encourage self-directed growth rather than dependency on your feedback?

Tell me about a time when you helped create a culture of peer coaching within a team or organization. What steps did you take, and what impact did you observe?

Areas to Cover:

• Their vision for a peer coaching culture
• Specific initiatives or structures they implemented
• How they modeled effective coaching behaviors
• Methods for encouraging participation and buy-in
• Challenges encountered and how they addressed them
• Metrics or observations of success
• Lessons learned about culture change

Follow-Up Questions:

• How did you address resistance or skepticism about peer coaching?
• What formal or informal structures helped sustain the coaching culture?
• How did you encourage peer coaching across hierarchical levels or departments?
• What unexpected benefits emerged from establishing this culture?

Describe a situation where you had to adapt your coaching style to effectively support someone with a different background, perspective, or learning style than your own.

Areas to Cover:

• The specific differences they needed to navigate
• How they recognized the need to adapt their approach
• The process of understanding the other person's needs
• Specific adjustments they made to their coaching
• Challenges faced in finding the right approach
• The outcome of their adapted coaching method
• What they learned about coaching flexibility

Follow-Up Questions:

• How did you identify that your usual approach wasn't working?
• What specific clues or feedback helped you understand how to adapt?
• How did this experience change your general approach to coaching?
• What techniques have you found most useful when coaching diverse individuals?

Tell me about a time when you leveraged peer coaching to help drive innovation or problem-solving within a team.

Areas to Cover:

• The specific challenge or opportunity the team faced
• How they structured the peer coaching approach
• Techniques used to stimulate creative thinking
• How they balanced guidance with exploration
• The collaborative dynamics that emerged
• Specific innovations or solutions that resulted
• The impact on the team's problem-solving capabilities

Follow-Up Questions:

• How did you create psychological safety for people to share unusual ideas?
• What specific questioning techniques helped unblock creative thinking?
• How did you help the team move from ideas to implementation?
• What have you learned about the relationship between coaching and innovation?

Describe your approach to balancing advocacy (sharing your expertise) with inquiry (asking questions to help others develop their thinking) in peer coaching situations.

Areas to Cover:

• Their philosophy about when to advise versus when to coach
• How they assess what approach is needed in different situations
• Specific examples of effective transitions between modes
• Techniques they use for powerful questioning
• How they share expertise without imposing solutions
• Challenges they've faced in finding the right balance
• How they evaluate whether their approach is working

Follow-Up Questions:

• How do you recognize when someone needs direct guidance versus coaching?
• What signals tell you that you might be offering too much advice?
• What types of questions have you found most effective for developing others' thinking?
• How has your balance of advocacy and inquiry evolved over time?

Tell me about a time when you helped a peer develop greater confidence in their abilities. What approach did you take?

Areas to Cover:

• The specific situation and confidence challenges
• Their assessment of the root causes of low confidence
• The coaching approach they designed
• How they balanced challenge with support
• Specific affirmation techniques they employed
• How they helped create successful experiences
• Signs of increased confidence they observed

Follow-Up Questions:

• How did you identify the underlying causes of their confidence issues?
• What specific language or techniques did you use to build their self-belief?
• How did you help them recognize and celebrate their progress?
• What have you learned about the relationship between coaching and confidence?

Describe a situation where you used peer coaching to help address a conflict or misunderstanding between team members.

Areas to Cover:

• The nature of the conflict and their role in the situation
• How they established trust with both parties
• The coaching framework or approach they employed
• Techniques used to foster understanding and empathy
• How they remained neutral while facilitating resolution
• The outcome of their intervention
• Lessons learned about coaching through conflict

Follow-Up Questions:

• How did you establish yourself as a trusted coach in this sensitive situation?
• What specific questions or techniques helped parties see each other's perspectives?
• How did you know when to step back and let the parties work things out directly?
• What would you do differently if faced with a similar situation in the future?

Tell me about your most meaningful experience with peer coaching. What made it so impactful?

Areas to Cover:

• The specific context of the coaching relationship
• Key elements that made the experience meaningful
• Transformative moments or breakthroughs
• The depth of the relationship that developed
• Specific outcomes or changes that resulted
• How this experience shaped their coaching philosophy
• Lessons they still carry with them today

Follow-Up Questions:

• What specific qualities in the relationship made this experience stand out?
• How did trust develop between you and the other person?
• What specific moments or conversations were most transformative?
• How has this experience influenced how you approach peer coaching today?

Frequently Asked Questions

What's the difference between peer coaching and mentoring?

While both involve supporting others' development, peer coaching typically occurs between colleagues of similar experience levels who exchange reciprocal support. Mentoring usually involves a more experienced person guiding someone with less experience. Peer coaching focuses more on drawing out solutions through questioning and reflection rather than directly advising, and the relationship is generally more reciprocal and equal in nature.

How do I assess whether a candidate truly values peer coaching versus just saying what they think I want to hear?

Look for specific examples with detailed descriptions of their coaching process and results. Strong candidates will describe challenges they faced in coaching relationships, what they learned from failures, and how they've evolved their approach. Also listen for whether they emphasize mutual learning in their examples or primarily talk about helping others without mentioning what they gained themselves.

Should I prioritize peer coaching abilities equally for all positions in my organization?

While peer coaching is valuable across most roles, its importance may vary depending on the position. For collaborative team environments, leadership roles, and positions involving knowledge sharing or innovation, peer coaching abilities should be prioritized highly. For highly independent roles or those with limited team interaction, it might be weighted less heavily, though still considered a valuable skill.

How can I determine if a candidate will be both a good coach and receptive to being coached?

Ask questions about both sides of the peer coaching relationship. Listen for how candidates describe receiving feedback and making changes based on others' input. The best candidates will demonstrate humility about their own growth areas while showing confidence in their ability to support others. Also, notice whether they naturally ask questions during the interview that demonstrate curiosity about your perspective.

How many peer coaching questions should I include in an interview?

For roles where peer coaching is a primary competency, include 3-4 questions that explore different aspects of coaching ability. For other positions, 1-2 well-crafted questions that assess both coaching and being coached can be sufficient. Use follow-up questions to dig deeper rather than covering more scenarios with surface-level responses.

Interested in a full interview guide with Peer Coaching as a key trait? Sign up for Yardstick and build it for free.