Effective coaching is a transformative skill that enables organizations to develop talent, improve performance, and create a culture of continuous growth. According to the International Coaching Federation, organizations with strong coaching cultures report higher employee engagement and revenue growth compared to their peers. The ability to coach effectively encompasses listening deeply, asking powerful questions, providing constructive feedback, and helping others discover their own solutions—all while building trust and psychological safety.

At its core, coaching is about unlocking potential and helping individuals and teams develop the capabilities they need to excel. A skilled coach doesn't just solve problems for others but empowers them to develop their own problem-solving abilities. In organizational settings, coaching manifests through formal development conversations, ongoing feedback, team facilitation, performance improvement discussions, and even day-to-day interactions that build capabilities and confidence.

For hiring managers seeking coaching talent, the interview process must reveal not just a candidate's theoretical knowledge of coaching principles, but their actual experience applying these skills in real situations. Behavioral interviewing is particularly effective for evaluating coaching capability, as it requires candidates to describe specific instances where they've demonstrated coaching competencies. When evaluating candidates, listen for evidence of empathy, adaptability in their coaching approach, patience with different learning styles, and the ability to balance supportive encouragement with constructive challenge.

Using the behavioral questions below, you can gain valuable insights into how candidates have actually coached others in past situations. Remember to use follow-up questions to probe deeper, as the richest information often comes from exploring the nuances of how a candidate approached a coaching situation. Also consider using a structured interview scorecard to objectively evaluate coaching competencies across candidates.

Interview Questions

Tell me about a time when you helped someone develop a skill they were struggling with. How did you approach coaching them?

Areas to Cover:

• Assessment methods used to identify the specific skill gap
• The coaching approach selected and why it was appropriate for this situation
• How they built trust with the person they were coaching
• Techniques used to keep the person motivated during the learning process
• How they measured improvement in the skill
• Adjustments made to the coaching approach if the initial methods weren't working
• Long-term outcomes of the coaching intervention

Follow-Up Questions:

• What was your initial assessment of why they were struggling with this skill?
• How did you tailor your coaching approach to this person's specific learning style?
• What challenges did you face during the coaching process, and how did you overcome them?
• How did you know when your coaching had been successful?

Describe a situation where you needed to provide difficult feedback to someone you were coaching. How did you handle it?

Areas to Cover:

• The nature of the difficult feedback that needed to be delivered
• How they prepared for the feedback conversation
• The specific approach and communication techniques used
• How they ensured the feedback was specific and actionable
• The person's initial reaction to the feedback
• How they maintained the coaching relationship after delivering tough feedback
• The outcomes that resulted from the feedback conversation

Follow-Up Questions:

• What made this feedback particularly challenging to deliver?
• How did you create psychological safety before providing the feedback?
• If the person became defensive, how did you respond?
• What did you learn about delivering difficult feedback from this experience?

Tell me about a time when you coached someone who had a very different personality or working style from your own. How did you adapt your approach?

Areas to Cover:

• Their process for understanding the person's unique personality and working style
• Specific adaptations they made to their coaching approach
• Challenges encountered in bridging style differences
• Communication techniques used to ensure understanding
• How they checked their own biases or preferences
• Results of their adapted coaching approach
• What they learned about coaching diverse personality types

Follow-Up Questions:

• How did you initially recognize that your usual coaching approach needed to be adapted?
• What specific aspects of their personality or working style required the most adjustment from you?
• Were there any misunderstandings that arose from your different styles, and how did you address them?
• How has this experience influenced your coaching approach with others?

Describe your experience coaching a team through a significant change or challenge. What was your approach?

Areas to Cover:

• The nature of the change or challenge the team was facing
• How they assessed the team's readiness and capability
• Their process for establishing team coaching goals
• Specific team coaching techniques they employed
• How they balanced individual and group coaching needs
• Obstacles encountered and how they were overcome
• Measurable outcomes achieved through the team coaching

Follow-Up Questions:

• How did you balance supporting individuals versus addressing team dynamics?
• What resistance did you encounter, and how did you address it?
• How did you help the team maintain momentum throughout the process?
• What would you do differently if you were coaching a similar team through change again?

Tell me about a coaching relationship that didn't go as well as you hoped. What happened, and what did you learn from it?

Areas to Cover:

• The context of the coaching relationship
• Their honest assessment of what went wrong
• Signs they observed that the coaching wasn't working
• Actions taken to try to improve the situation
• How they managed their own reactions and emotions
• What they learned about themselves as a coach
• How they've applied these lessons to subsequent coaching relationships

Follow-Up Questions:

• At what point did you realize the coaching relationship wasn't working effectively?
• What do you think were the primary factors that contributed to the issues?
• How did you try to address the situation once you recognized there were problems?
• How has this experience shaped your approach to establishing new coaching relationships?

Describe a situation where you helped someone identify and leverage their unique strengths. What was your approach?

Areas to Cover:

• Methods used to identify the person's strengths
• How they helped the person gain awareness of their strengths
• Ways they connected strengths to performance outcomes
• How they helped the person apply strengths in new ways
• Challenges encountered in the strengths-based coaching
• Results achieved through the strengths focus
• Balance of addressing development areas while focusing on strengths

Follow-Up Questions:

• What techniques or tools did you use to help identify their strengths?
• How did you help them see strengths they might have been overlooking?
• How did focusing on strengths impact this person's confidence and performance?
• How do you balance focusing on strengths versus addressing development needs?

Tell me about a time when you coached someone who was resistant to your guidance. How did you handle this situation?

Areas to Cover:

• Signs of resistance they observed
• Their assessment of the underlying causes of resistance
• Approaches used to build trust and reduce defensiveness
• How they adapted their coaching style to address the resistance
• Communication techniques that proved effective
• The turning point in the relationship, if there was one
• Results achieved after working through the resistance
• What they learned about coaching resistant individuals

Follow-Up Questions:

• What do you think was causing their resistance initially?
• How did you maintain your patience and professionalism despite the resistance?
• What specific approach or technique finally broke through the resistance?
• How has this experience influenced how you establish coaching relationships now?

Describe a coaching success story you're particularly proud of. What made it successful?

Areas to Cover:

• The initial situation and goals for coaching
• Their assessment of the individual's needs and readiness
• The coaching approach and methods used
• Key turning points in the coaching relationship
• How progress was measured
• The ultimate outcomes achieved
• What made this particular coaching relationship successful
• Lessons learned that they've applied elsewhere

Follow-Up Questions:

• What specific coaching techniques proved most effective in this situation?
• How did you know when to push this person versus when to be more supportive?
• What surprised you most about this coaching experience?
• How did you measure the impact of your coaching beyond the obvious outcomes?

Tell me about a time when you had to coach someone on a skill or topic that wasn't your strongest area of expertise. How did you approach this?

Areas to Cover:

• How they assessed their own knowledge gaps
• Actions taken to increase their understanding of the subject
• Resources or experts they leveraged to support the coaching
• How they maintained credibility while acknowledging limitations
• Their approach to learning alongside the person they were coaching
• What made the coaching effective despite not being an expert
• How this experience influenced their coaching philosophy

Follow-Up Questions:

• How did you prepare yourself to coach effectively in an area where you weren't an expert?
• How did you balance being honest about your limitations while maintaining credibility?
• What resources or support did you leverage to enhance the coaching experience?
• How has this experience changed your approach to coaching in areas outside your expertise?

Describe a time when you needed to help someone recognize a blind spot or limitation they weren't aware of. How did you approach this delicate situation?

Areas to Cover:

• How they identified the blind spot or limitation
• Their preparation for the sensitive conversation
• Techniques used to create psychological safety
• The specific approach used to promote self-awareness
• How they managed potential defensiveness
• Methods used to confirm understanding and commitment to change
• Follow-up actions and support provided
• Outcomes from addressing the blind spot

Follow-Up Questions:

• How did you know this was a true blind spot versus simply a different perspective?
• What signals told you the timing was right to address this blind spot?
• How did you frame the conversation to minimize defensiveness?
• What was the most challenging part of this conversation, and how did you handle it?

Tell me about your approach to measuring the effectiveness of your coaching. How do you know when your coaching has been successful?

Areas to Cover:

• Specific metrics or indicators they use to measure coaching impact
• How they establish baseline measurements before coaching
• Methods for gathering feedback on coaching effectiveness
• Their approach to ongoing progress assessment
• How they define "success" in different coaching contexts
• Ways they've adjusted their approach based on measurement insights
• Examples of how measurement has improved their coaching

Follow-Up Questions:

• What specific metrics have you found most valuable in assessing coaching effectiveness?
• How do you separate the impact of your coaching from other factors influencing performance?
• How do you gather honest feedback about your coaching approach?
• How has your approach to measuring coaching effectiveness evolved over time?

Describe a situation where you helped someone prepare for a significant career transition or new leadership role. What was your coaching approach?

Areas to Cover:

• How they assessed readiness for the transition
• Their process for identifying development priorities
• The coaching framework or model they employed
• Specific tools or techniques they utilized
• How they balanced addressing technical skills versus leadership capabilities
• Methods for building confidence during the transition
• How they measured progress and success
• Outcomes achieved through the coaching

Follow-Up Questions:

• What were the most critical development areas you identified for this transition?
• How did you help them navigate the emotional aspects of a significant change?
• What specific techniques did you use to help them develop new capabilities quickly?
• How did you support them through inevitable setbacks during the transition?

Tell me about a time when you had to adjust your coaching style dramatically for a specific individual. What prompted this, and how did you adapt?

Areas to Cover:

• Signs that indicated their usual approach wasn't working
• Their process for diagnosing what needed to change
• Specific adjustments made to their coaching style
• Challenges encountered in making these adaptations
• How they communicated changes to maintain trust
• Results of the adapted approach
• What they learned about flexibility in coaching

Follow-Up Questions:

• What specific cues told you that your initial coaching approach wasn't effective?
• Which aspects of your coaching style were most difficult to adjust?
• How did you ensure your adapted approach still aligned with your core coaching values?
• How has this experience influenced your initial approach with new coaching relationships?

Describe a time when you helped someone recover from a significant setback or failure. How did you coach them through this difficult situation?

Areas to Cover:

• The nature of the setback and its impact on the person
• How they created psychological safety to discuss the failure
• Their approach to balancing empathy with accountability
• Specific techniques used to rebuild confidence
• How they helped extract learning from the experience
• The process for developing a recovery plan
• Results achieved after the coaching intervention
• What they learned about coaching through adversity

Follow-Up Questions:

• How did you help them maintain perspective during this challenging time?
• What was most important in helping them rebuild their confidence?
• How did you balance empathy with the need to move forward productively?
• What was the most challenging aspect of coaching someone through this failure?

Tell me about a situation where you coached someone to achieve a goal they initially thought was impossible. What approach did you take?

Areas to Cover:

• The nature of the challenging goal
• Their assessment of the actual versus perceived barriers
• How they built the person's belief in their capabilities
• The goal-setting and action planning process they used
• Techniques for maintaining motivation during difficult phases
• How they helped overcome setbacks and obstacles
• The ultimate outcome of the coaching
• Key factors that contributed to the successful achievement

Follow-Up Questions:

• What did you identify as the main limiting beliefs or barriers you needed to address?
• How did you break down the seemingly impossible goal into achievable steps?
• What specific techniques did you use to build their confidence and motivation?
• How did you help them persist when they encountered inevitable obstacles?

Frequently Asked Questions

What's the difference between coaching and managing?

While management focuses on directing work and ensuring task completion, coaching is about developing capabilities and potential. Managers often tell employees what to do, while coaches ask questions that help individuals discover their own solutions. Effective leaders typically combine both approaches, knowing when to direct and when to develop. In interviews, look for candidates who understand this distinction and can articulate when each approach is appropriate.

How can I tell if someone is truly skilled at coaching versus just talking about coaching concepts?

The key is to focus on specific behavioral examples and probe for details. Skilled coaches will readily share concrete situations, their exact approach, challenges they faced, and measurable outcomes. They'll describe their thought process and adaptations they made based on individual needs. Be wary of candidates who speak only in generalizations or theoretical terms without providing real examples from their experience.

How many coaching-focused questions should I include in an interview?

For roles where coaching is a primary responsibility, dedicate at least 3-4 behavioral questions specifically to coaching competencies. For roles where coaching is important but not the main focus, 1-2 well-chosen questions may be sufficient. Remember that quality is more important than quantity - it's better to thoroughly explore fewer examples than to superficially cover many situations.

Should coaching ability be weighted differently for different levels of leadership?

Yes. While coaching skills are valuable at all levels, they become increasingly critical at higher leadership levels where developing others is a core responsibility. For senior leaders, coaching competency should typically be weighted more heavily in your evaluation criteria, as these individuals will shape the coaching culture of entire teams or departments. For individual contributors or first-level managers, technical skills might be weighted more heavily relative to coaching ability.

How can we develop coaching skills in candidates who show potential but aren't fully developed in this area?

Look for candidates who demonstrate coachability, self-awareness, and a growth mindset. These qualities suggest they can develop coaching capabilities with proper support. Consider implementing training programs, external coaching certification, mentorship from skilled coaches within your organization, and regular feedback on coaching interactions. Creating opportunities for practice with safe feedback is essential for skill development.

Would you like a complete interview plan that has Coaching as a key competency? Sign up for Yardstick for free to get started.