Influential Leadership is the ability to positively impact others' actions, decisions, opinions, or thinking through relationship building, persuasion, and collaboration rather than formal authority or power. In the workplace, it's evaluated by examining how candidates strategically build trust, communicate effectively, and motivate others to achieve shared goals.

Influential leadership is essential in today's collaborative work environments where success often depends on the ability to work across teams, departments, and sometimes organizations without direct authority. This competency manifests in many ways - from how individuals navigate stakeholder management and build coalitions for change, to how they articulate compelling visions and gain buy-in for new initiatives. Influential leaders excel at understanding others' perspectives, building genuine relationships, communicating persuasively, and creating environments where people feel motivated to follow their lead.

When evaluating candidates for Influential Leadership, interviewers should listen for specific examples that demonstrate relationship-building skills, strategic persuasion tactics, and the ability to inspire action in others. The most revealing responses will include not just successful outcomes but also the candidate's thought process, how they adapted their approach to different stakeholders, and what they learned from both successes and failures. By using behavioral questions and probing for details with thoughtful follow-up questions, you can gain valuable insights into a candidate's potential to lead through influence in your organization.

Interview Questions

Tell me about a time when you needed to gain buy-in for an important initiative from people who initially disagreed with your approach.

Areas to Cover:

• The nature of the initiative and why it was important
• Who the key stakeholders were and their initial objections
• The strategy used to understand stakeholders' perspectives
• How the candidate tailored their approach to different stakeholders
• Specific actions taken to build trust and credibility
• How the candidate communicated the value proposition
• The outcome and impact of gaining this buy-in
• Lessons learned about influencing others

Follow-Up Questions:

• What specific objections did you face and how did you address each one?
• How did you adapt your approach based on the different stakeholders involved?
• What would you do differently if you faced a similar situation again?
• How did you know when you had successfully gained their buy-in?

Describe a situation where you had to influence a decision without having formal authority over the decision-makers.

Areas to Cover:

• The context and what was at stake
• The candidate's relationship with the decision-makers
• The strategy used to build influence
• Specific communication techniques employed
• How the candidate overcame resistance or skepticism
• What data or evidence was leveraged
• The result of their influence attempt
• How this experience shaped their approach to influence

Follow-Up Questions:

• What was the most challenging aspect of influencing without authority?
• How did you establish credibility with the decision-makers?
• Were there any unexpected obstacles you encountered, and how did you handle them?
• What alternative approaches did you consider before choosing your strategy?

Share an experience where you had to build relationships across different departments or teams to accomplish an important goal.

Areas to Cover:

• The nature of the cross-functional goal
• Initial challenges in relationship building
• Specific steps taken to establish trust
• How the candidate navigated different team cultures or priorities
• Communication strategies used to maintain alignment
• How conflicts or competing interests were resolved
• The outcome of the collaborative effort
• Key relationship-building lessons learned

Follow-Up Questions:

• How did you initially approach building relationships with people you didn't know well?
• What resistance did you encounter and how did you overcome it?
• How did you ensure continued communication and alignment across the teams?
• How have you maintained these relationships after the project ended?

Tell me about a time when you had to persuade senior leadership to support a significant change.

Areas to Cover:

• The change being proposed and its potential impact
• The candidate's preparation and research
• Understanding of senior leaders' priorities and concerns
• Strategy for framing the proposal to align with leadership priorities
• Data and evidence used to support the case
• How the candidate handled pushback or tough questions
• The ultimate outcome and implementation process
• Lessons about influencing upward

Follow-Up Questions:

• How did you tailor your message to address leadership's specific concerns?
• What was the most challenging question or objection you received?
• How did you build support before the formal presentation?
• How did you follow up after getting initial support?

Describe a situation where you influenced a team to embrace an unpopular but necessary decision or change.

Areas to Cover:

• The unpopular decision and why it was necessary
• The sources of resistance or concern
• How the candidate assessed the situation before acting
• The communication strategy employed
• How the candidate showed empathy while maintaining direction
• Specific actions taken to bring people along
• How resistance was addressed constructively
• The outcome and lessons learned

Follow-Up Questions:

• How did you identify and address the root causes of resistance?
• What specific concerns did team members have and how did you address them?
• How did you maintain morale during this challenging period?
• What would you have done differently in retrospect?

Share an example of when you had to convince someone to accept a new idea or approach that was outside their comfort zone.

Areas to Cover:

• The idea or approach and why it represented a stretch
• Understanding of the person's concerns or hesitations
• How trust was established or leveraged
• The persuasion techniques used
• How risks or concerns were addressed
• The process of moving from resistance to acceptance
• The outcome of the influence attempt
• Insights gained about helping others embrace change

Follow-Up Questions:

• What signals told you they were uncomfortable with the idea?
• How did you help make the unfamiliar seem less threatening?
• What specific concerns did they express and how did you address each one?
• How has this experience affected how you introduce new ideas now?

Tell me about a time you had to align multiple stakeholders with competing priorities toward a common goal.

Areas to Cover:

• The situation and the competing priorities at play
• The diverse stakeholders involved
• Strategy for finding common ground or shared interests
• How conflicts or disagreements were handled
• Communication approaches used to build consensus
• How the candidate balanced different needs
• The eventual outcome of the alignment effort
• Reflections on stakeholder management

Follow-Up Questions:

• How did you identify what each stakeholder valued most?
• What compromises were necessary to reach alignment?
• How did you maintain momentum when disagreements arose?
• What techniques were most effective in bringing people to consensus?

Describe a time when you successfully advocated for a resource, budget, or approval that was initially denied.

Areas to Cover:

• The request and its importance to business objectives
• Understanding of the initial denial rationale
• How the candidate reassessed and reformulated the approach
• Data or evidence gathered to strengthen the case
• Relationship building or coalition forming efforts
• The revised persuasion strategy
• How objections were addressed
• The outcome and implementation

Follow-Up Questions:

• What did you learn from the initial denial that helped you succeed later?
• How did you reframe your request to better align with decision-makers' priorities?
• What additional support or allies did you enlist, and how?
• What was the key turning point in changing minds?

Share an example of when you had to influence a resistant colleague or team member to collaborate on an important project.

Areas to Cover:

• The context and the source of resistance
• The candidate's approach to understanding underlying concerns
• Relationship-building techniques employed
• How the candidate adapted their communication style
• Specific actions taken to build trust
• How the value of collaboration was conveyed
• The evolution of the working relationship
• The outcome and lessons learned

Follow-Up Questions:

• What do you think was the root cause of their resistance?
• How did you demonstrate respect for their perspective while still moving forward?
• What specific approach finally helped break through the resistance?
• How did the relationship evolve after this collaboration?

Tell me about a time when you successfully built consensus among a group with diverse opinions or perspectives.

Areas to Cover:

• The situation requiring consensus
• The diverse perspectives represented
• How the candidate facilitated productive dialogue
• Techniques used to identify common ground
• How disagreements were handled constructively
• The process of moving from individual positions to group alignment
• The final consensus achieved
• Insights about facilitating group alignment

Follow-Up Questions:

• How did you ensure all perspectives were heard and considered?
• What techniques did you use to bridge significant differences in viewpoint?
• Were there any breakthrough moments in the consensus-building process?
• How did you handle the strongest disagreements?

Describe a situation where you had to use data or evidence to influence an important decision.

Areas to Cover:

• The decision context and its significance
• How the candidate identified relevant data needs
• The process of gathering and analyzing information
• How data was translated into compelling insights
• The presentation approach used
• How technical information was made accessible
• The impact of the data-driven approach
• Lessons about evidence-based influence

Follow-Up Questions:

• How did you determine what data would be most persuasive?
• How did you make complex data accessible and meaningful?
• What challenges did you face in gathering or presenting the data?
• How did the data change the trajectory of the decision?

Share an experience where you had to influence the culture or norms within a team or organization.

Areas to Cover:

• The cultural aspect being influenced and why change was needed
• The candidate's approach to understanding the existing culture
• How resistance to cultural change was anticipated and addressed
• The influence strategy deployed
• How the candidate modeled desired behaviors
• The timeline and milestones of the cultural shift
• Measurable impacts of the cultural change
• Reflections on leading cultural transformation

Follow-Up Questions:

• How did you identify which aspects of culture needed to change?
• What signals told you that cultural norms were beginning to shift?
• How did you handle those who were strongly attached to the status quo?
• What surprised you most about the process of influencing culture?

Tell me about a time when you failed to gain buy-in for an idea or initiative that you believed in strongly. What did you learn?

Areas to Cover:

• The idea or initiative and why it was important
• The approach initially taken to influence others
• Where and why the influence attempt fell short
• How the candidate responded to the setback
• What insights were gained about effective influence
• Changes made to approach based on this experience
• How these lessons have been applied in subsequent situations
• Perspective gained on the original idea with hindsight

Follow-Up Questions:

• Looking back, what were the early warning signs that your approach wasn't working?
• What specific aspects of your influence strategy would you change now?
• How has this experience changed how you approach gaining buy-in?
• Did you eventually achieve your goal through a different approach?

Describe a situation where you successfully changed someone's strongly held opinion or belief.

Areas to Cover:

• The context and the nature of the strongly held belief
• The relationship with the person
• The approach to understanding their perspective
• Communication techniques used to open dialogue
• How evidence or new perspectives were introduced
• The process of opinion shift and key turning points
• The outcome and relationship impact
• Insights about changing deep-seated views

Follow-Up Questions:

• How did you create a safe space for them to reconsider their position?
• What was the most effective element in changing their perspective?
• How did you know their view was genuinely changing rather than just being suppressed?
• How has this experience informed how you approach similar situations?

Share an example of how you've used storytelling or narrative to influence others effectively.

Areas to Cover:

• The situation requiring influence
• Why storytelling was chosen as an approach
• How the story was constructed to resonate with the audience
• Elements that made the narrative compelling
• How data or facts were incorporated
• The audience response and engagement
• The outcome and impact of the storytelling approach
• Lessons about narrative as an influence tool

Follow-Up Questions:

• How did you tailor your story to your specific audience?
• What elements made your story particularly effective?
• How did you balance emotional appeal with logical reasoning?
• When have you found storytelling to be more effective than other influence approaches?

Frequently Asked Questions

Why focus on past behaviors rather than asking candidates how they would handle hypothetical situations?

Past behaviors are much more reliable predictors of future performance than hypothetical scenarios. When candidates describe what they've actually done, rather than what they think they might do, you get insight into their real capabilities, thought processes, and learned experiences. Behavioral questions also reduce the likelihood of rehearsed, idealized answers since candidates must draw from their unique experiences.

How many of these questions should I include in an interview?

Rather than trying to cover all these questions, select 3-4 that are most relevant to your specific role and organization. This allows time for thorough follow-up questions and deeper exploration of examples. Quality of discussion is more valuable than quantity of questions. Different interviewers can also focus on different aspects of Influential Leadership if you're conducting panel interviews.

How can I tell if a candidate is exaggerating their influence in the situations they describe?

Listen for specificity and complexity in their answers. Authentic examples typically include details about challenges faced, how they adapted their approach, and lessons learned – not just successful outcomes. Effective follow-up questions like "What specifically did you say?" or "How did others initially respond?" can help verify the depth of their experience. Also, note whether they share credit appropriately and acknowledge the role of others.

Should I evaluate Influential Leadership differently for individual contributor roles versus management positions?

Yes, while the fundamental skills are similar, the context and application differ. For individual contributors, focus on influence without authority, peer collaboration, and upward influence. For managers, emphasize coaching others on influence skills, influencing across departments, and building coalitions for larger initiatives. Adjust your expectations for the scope and scale of influence based on the role level.

How does Influential Leadership relate to other competencies like communication skills or emotional intelligence?

Influential Leadership encompasses aspects of several related competencies. Strong communication skills are necessary but not sufficient – influence requires strategic application of those skills. Similarly, emotional intelligence enables the relationship building and perspective-taking crucial for influence. When evaluating Influential Leadership, you're looking at how candidates integrate these competencies into a cohesive approach to moving people toward shared goals.

Interested in a full interview guide with Influential Leadership as a key trait? Sign up for Yardstick and build it for free.