Effective copywriting is the art and science of creating persuasive, clear, and engaging written content that compels audiences to take action. In a professional setting, it involves crafting messaging that resonates with target audiences while achieving specific business objectives, whether that's generating leads, boosting sales, or building brand awareness.

When evaluating candidates for copywriting roles, it's essential to look beyond basic writing abilities. The most successful copywriters combine creativity with strategic thinking, understand audience psychology, and can adapt their voice to different platforms and purposes. They balance artistic expression with data-driven decision-making, creating content that not only captures attention but also delivers measurable results.

The evaluation process should examine multiple dimensions of copywriting skill, including conceptual thinking, research capabilities, collaboration with stakeholders, revision processes, and the ability to work within brand guidelines while still producing fresh ideas. For more junior roles, focus on fundamental writing skills and creativity; for senior positions, strategic thinking and proven results become increasingly important.

To effectively assess these skills, behavioral interview questions that explore past experiences will provide far more insight than hypothetical scenarios. By asking candidates to describe specific writing projects, their approaches to challenges, and the results they achieved, you'll gain a complete picture of their capabilities and fit for your team. Follow-up questions are crucial for diving deeper into their processes and understanding how they might handle similar situations at your organization.

Interview Questions

Tell me about a time when you had to create copy for a product or service you weren't familiar with. How did you approach this challenge?

Areas to Cover:

• Research methods used to understand the unfamiliar product/service
• How they gained subject matter expertise quickly
• Their process for translating technical or complex information into compelling copy
• Stakeholders they collaborated with during the process
• Challenges faced in the learning curve
• How they evaluated the effectiveness of their copy
• Lessons learned that they applied to future projects

Follow-Up Questions:

• What specific research techniques yielded the most valuable insights?
• How did you determine which features or benefits to emphasize in your copy?
• How did you validate that your messaging would resonate with the target audience?
• What would you do differently if faced with a similar situation now?

Describe a situation where you had to significantly revise copy based on feedback. How did you handle it?

Areas to Cover:

• Nature of the feedback received
• Their initial reaction to critical feedback
• Process for interpreting and implementing feedback
• How they balanced multiple stakeholders' input
• What they learned from the revision process
• How the final version differed from the original
• Impact of the revisions on the project's success

Follow-Up Questions:

• How did you prioritize which feedback to address first?
• Were there any suggestions you pushed back on, and if so, how did you handle that conversation?
• How did you maintain the core message while accommodating the requested changes?
• How did this experience influence your approach to the initial drafting process for future projects?

Share an example of when you had to write copy with significant constraints (tight word count, strict brand guidelines, regulatory requirements, etc.). How did you work within these limitations?

Areas to Cover:

• Specific constraints they faced
• Creative process for working within boundaries
• Techniques used to maintain effectiveness despite limitations
• How they prioritized information when space was limited
• Stakeholders involved in approving the content
• Results achieved despite the constraints
• How they balanced creativity with compliance

Follow-Up Questions:

• What was your thought process for deciding what to include and what to cut?
• How did you ensure your copy remained engaging despite the constraints?
• What tools or techniques did you use to track and adhere to the requirements?
• How did this experience shape your approach to other projects with similar constraints?

Tell me about a copywriting project that didn't perform as well as expected. What happened and what did you learn from it?

Areas to Cover:

• Context of the underperforming project
• Metrics used to measure performance
• Analysis of what went wrong
• Actions taken to address the issues
• How they communicated challenges to stakeholders
• Specific lessons learned from the experience
• How they applied these lessons to subsequent projects

Follow-Up Questions:

• What early warning signs might you have missed?
• How did you diagnose the root cause of the underperformance?
• What would you do differently if you could tackle this project again?
• How has this experience changed your approach to measuring success in your copywriting?

Describe a time when you had to create copy for multiple platforms or channels from the same campaign. How did you adapt your writing while maintaining a consistent message?

Areas to Cover:

• Campaign goals and platforms involved
• Process for adapting content across channels
• How they maintained brand voice while optimizing for each platform
• Challenges in creating platform-specific content
• Collaboration with other team members (designers, social media specialists, etc.)
• Performance across different channels
• Insights gained about platform-specific writing

Follow-Up Questions:

• How did you prioritize which platforms to focus on first?
• What specific adaptations did you make for each channel and why?
• How did you track which messages performed best on which platforms?
• What surprised you about how the same campaign performed across different channels?

Share an example of when you had to write copy on a topic that personally didn't interest you. How did you find a way to create engaging content?

Areas to Cover:

• The subject matter and context for the project
• Techniques used to generate personal interest or connection
• Research approach to find compelling angles
• Methods for maintaining enthusiasm in the writing
• Whether they disclosed their initial lack of interest to teammates
• Quality of the final product and reception
• Professional growth from the experience

Follow-Up Questions:

• What specific strategies helped you engage with the subject matter?
• How did you ensure your personal feelings didn't negatively impact the copy?
• What did you discover about the topic that surprised you?
• How has this experience helped you approach other challenging topics?

Tell me about a time when you had to write copy that would appeal to an audience very different from yourself. How did you ensure it would resonate with them?

Areas to Cover:

• The audience they needed to reach
• Research methods used to understand the target demographic
• Resources or people consulted to gain perspective
• How they tested assumptions about the audience
• Techniques used to write authentically for this group
• Results and feedback from the target audience
• Learnings about writing for diverse audiences

Follow-Up Questions:

• What was the most challenging aspect of connecting with this particular audience?
• How did you validate that your messaging would resonate with them?
• What assumptions did you have that proved incorrect?
• How has this experience informed your approach to audience research?

Describe a situation where you collaborated with designers or other creative professionals to develop content. How did you approach this collaboration?

Areas to Cover:

• Project context and team composition
• Process for aligning copy with visual elements
• Communication methods with creative partners
• How they handled creative differences
• Their understanding of design principles as they relate to copy
• Mutual influence between copy and design elements
• Final outcome and effectiveness of the collaboration

Follow-Up Questions:

• At what stage of the project did you begin collaborating with designers?
• How did you ensure your copy complemented the visual direction?
• What compromises did you make to accommodate design needs?
• What did you learn about effective collaboration with design professionals?

Share an example of when you had to craft a complex message in a very simple, accessible way. What was your approach?

Areas to Cover:

• Nature of the complex information
• Target audience and their level of familiarity with the subject
• Techniques used to simplify without losing accuracy
• Process for identifying what information was essential
• Testing or feedback methods to ensure clarity
• Stakeholder management when simplifying technical information
• Results and audience comprehension

Follow-Up Questions:

• How did you determine which technical details could be omitted?
• What specific techniques did you use to make complex concepts more digestible?
• How did you balance simplicity with the need for comprehensive information?
• What feedback indicated whether you had achieved the right level of simplicity?

Tell me about a copywriting project where you had to meet an extremely tight deadline. How did you ensure quality while working under pressure?

Areas to Cover:

• Project context and timeline constraints
• Process adjustments made for speed
• Quality control measures despite time pressure
• Resource allocation and prioritization decisions
• Collaboration with others under deadline pressure
• Impact on final deliverable quality
• Stress management techniques employed

Follow-Up Questions:

• What tasks did you prioritize and which did you scale back due to time constraints?
• How did you modify your usual writing or editing process?
• What quality checks did you maintain despite the rush?
• What would you do differently next time you face a similar deadline?

Describe a situation where you had to create copy that generated measurable results (conversions, click-throughs, etc.). How did you approach this goal?

Areas to Cover:

• Business objectives and specific metrics targeted
• Research conducted before writing
• Strategic decisions in messaging and calls-to-action
• Testing methods or A/B variants created
• Results achieved and how they were measured
• Analysis of which elements contributed most to success
• How learnings were applied to future conversion-focused copy

Follow-Up Questions:

• What specific elements of your copy do you believe had the biggest impact on results?
• How did you incorporate the call to action into your messaging?
• What testing did you perform to optimize performance?
• How did data from this project influence your approach to subsequent projects?

Tell me about a time when you had to maintain a consistent brand voice across multiple pieces of content. How did you ensure coherence?

Areas to Cover:

• Brand context and voice characteristics
• Tools or resources used for maintaining consistency
• Process for internalizing the brand voice
• Quality control methods
• Feedback mechanisms to refine adherence to brand standards
• Challenges in maintaining voice across different content types
• Balance between consistency and context-appropriate variations

Follow-Up Questions:

• How did you familiarize yourself with the brand voice initially?
• What reference materials or tools did you create or use to maintain consistency?
• How did you handle situations where brand voice seemed at odds with a specific message?
• How did you onboard or guide others to maintain the same voice?

Share an example of when you had to integrate SEO requirements into compelling copy. How did you balance search optimization with engaging writing?

Areas to Cover:

• SEO requirements and business goals
• Research process for identifying keywords and search intent
• Techniques for natural keyword integration
• Collaboration with SEO specialists if applicable
• How they prioritized user experience vs. search algorithms
• Results from both engagement and search ranking perspectives
• Evolution of their approach to SEO copywriting

Follow-Up Questions:

• How did you research and select which keywords to target?
• What techniques did you use to incorporate keywords naturally?
• How did you measure the success of your SEO copy?
• What challenges did you face in balancing readability with optimization?

Describe a time when you created copy that successfully changed perceptions or behaviors. What approach did you take?

Areas to Cover:

• Original perceptions or behaviors that needed changing
• Target audience analysis
• Messaging strategy to influence change
• Psychological principles applied
• Testing or feedback mechanisms used
• Metrics that demonstrated successful change
• Insights gained about persuasive writing

Follow-Up Questions:

• How did you identify the most effective messaging approach?
• What objections or resistance did you anticipate and address?
• How did you measure the shift in perception or behavior?
• What elements of your copy do you believe were most persuasive?

Tell me about a time when you had to find a fresh angle for a common or seemingly boring topic. How did you make it engaging?

Areas to Cover:

• The topic and context of the assignment
• Research approach to find unique perspectives
• Creative techniques used to develop fresh angles
• How they tested or validated the approach
• Stakeholder reactions to the novel approach
• Audience reception and engagement
• Lessons about creating interest in routine subjects

Follow-Up Questions:

• What specific research methods helped you discover an interesting angle?
• How did you know your approach would resonate with the audience?
• What creative techniques do you regularly use to find fresh perspectives?
• How do you push through when initially struggling to find inspiration?

Frequently Asked Questions

What makes behavioral questions better than hypothetical scenarios when interviewing copywriters?

Behavioral questions based on past experiences provide concrete evidence of how candidates have actually handled real writing challenges. Unlike hypothetical scenarios, which only reveal what candidates think they might do, behavioral questions demonstrate proven skills, actual processes, and measurable results. This approach gives you insight into their problem-solving abilities, collaboration style, and how they've grown from experience.

How many copywriting questions should I include in an interview?

Rather than covering many questions superficially, it's more effective to explore 3-5 questions in depth with thorough follow-up. This allows candidates to provide detailed examples and gives you a more complete picture of their capabilities. Select questions that are most relevant to your specific role requirements, covering different aspects of copywriting from creativity to strategic thinking to collaboration.

How can I tell if a candidate is exaggerating their copywriting achievements?

Look for specificity and consistency in their responses. Strong candidates will provide detailed examples with concrete metrics, clearly articulate their process, acknowledge their role within team efforts, and discuss both successes and challenges openly. Ask follow-up questions about specific techniques used, metrics tracked, and lessons learned. If answers become vague or inconsistent when probed for details, this may indicate embellishment.

Should I evaluate entry-level and senior copywriter candidates differently?

Yes, absolutely. For entry-level candidates, focus more on fundamental writing skills, creativity, adaptability, and eagerness to learn. Their examples might come from academic projects, internships, or personal writing. For senior candidates, place greater emphasis on strategic thinking, leadership in the creative process, experience across multiple channels, demonstrated results, and their approach to mentoring junior writers.

How important is industry-specific copywriting experience?

While industry knowledge can be valuable, strong copywriting skills often transfer well across sectors. Look for candidates who demonstrate excellent research abilities, quick learning, and adaptability to different audiences and subjects. A copywriter with experience in a different industry but strong fundamentals may bring fresh perspectives that someone with only industry-specific experience might miss.

Interested in a full interview guide with Writing for Copywriter Roles as a key trait? Sign up for Yardstick and build it for free.