Effective Work Sample Exercises for Hiring an Innovation Manager

Innovation Managers are the catalysts for organizational growth and competitive advantage in today's rapidly evolving business landscape. They identify new opportunities, lead cross-functional teams, and transform creative ideas into tangible business outcomes. Finding the right person for this pivotal role requires more than just reviewing resumes and conducting standard interviews.

Traditional interview methods often fail to reveal a candidate's true capabilities in driving innovation. While candidates may eloquently describe their past experiences, these narratives don't necessarily demonstrate their ability to think strategically, generate novel ideas, or lead innovation initiatives in your specific organizational context.

Work samples and role-playing exercises provide a window into how candidates actually approach innovation challenges. They reveal thinking patterns, problem-solving approaches, and interpersonal skills that might otherwise remain hidden during conventional interviews. These practical assessments allow you to observe candidates in action, making decisions and demonstrating the very skills they'll need to succeed in the role.

The following four activities are designed to evaluate the essential competencies of an effective Innovation Manager: strategic thinking, creativity facilitation, project management, and the ability to communicate and champion innovation. By incorporating these exercises into your hiring process, you'll gain deeper insights into each candidate's capabilities and fit for your organization's innovation needs.

These exercises can be adapted to your company's specific industry and innovation challenges, providing a customized assessment that aligns with your organizational goals and culture. The result is a more informed hiring decision and a higher likelihood of selecting an Innovation Manager who will drive meaningful change and growth.

Activity #1: Innovation Opportunity Analysis

This exercise evaluates a candidate's ability to identify innovation opportunities by analyzing market trends, customer needs, and competitive landscapes. Strategic thinking is a fundamental skill for Innovation Managers who must constantly scan the environment for new possibilities and translate these insights into actionable innovation strategies.

Directions for the Company:

• Prepare a brief (1-2 page) document describing a real or fictional challenge in your industry that presents an opportunity for innovation.
• Include relevant market data, customer feedback, and competitive information, but intentionally leave some gaps that require the candidate to make reasonable assumptions.
• Provide the candidate with this document 24-48 hours before the interview.
• Allocate 20 minutes for the candidate's presentation and 10 minutes for questions and feedback.
• Prepare a small panel (2-3 people) to evaluate the presentation, ideally including someone from your product or strategy team.

Directions for the Candidate:

• Review the provided industry challenge and identify 2-3 potential innovation opportunities.
• For each opportunity, analyze its strategic fit, potential impact, and feasibility.
• Prepare a brief presentation (5-7 slides) outlining your analysis and recommendations.
• Be prepared to explain your thought process, including any assumptions you made where data was limited.
• Your presentation should demonstrate how you approach opportunity identification and strategic thinking.

Feedback Mechanism:

• After the presentation, provide specific feedback on one aspect the candidate did particularly well (e.g., depth of analysis, creative connections, strategic prioritization).
• Offer one constructive suggestion for improvement (e.g., considering additional stakeholders, refining the feasibility assessment).
• Ask the candidate to verbally revise one portion of their analysis based on this feedback, observing their adaptability and receptiveness to input.

Activity #2: Innovation Workshop Facilitation

This exercise assesses the candidate's ability to design and facilitate creative ideation sessions, a critical skill for Innovation Managers who must regularly engage cross-functional teams in generating and developing innovative concepts.

Directions for the Company:

• Define a specific innovation challenge relevant to your business (e.g., "How might we improve the customer onboarding experience?").
• Assemble a small group (3-4 people) from different departments to participate in the mini-workshop.
• Provide the candidate with the challenge statement and participant profiles 48 hours in advance.
• Allocate 30 minutes for the workshop facilitation and 15 minutes for debrief and feedback.
• Prepare to observe both the workshop design and the candidate's facilitation skills.

Directions for the Candidate:

• Design a 30-minute mini-workshop to generate innovative ideas addressing the provided challenge.
• Create a facilitation plan that includes a warm-up activity, an ideation technique, and a method for idea selection or refinement.
• Prepare any necessary materials or visual aids to support your workshop.
• During the session, demonstrate your ability to create a collaborative atmosphere, manage group dynamics, and guide participants toward innovative thinking.
• Be prepared to adapt your approach based on the group's responses and energy levels.

Feedback Mechanism:

• After the workshop, provide feedback on what worked well in the facilitation (e.g., engagement techniques, question framing, idea building).
• Offer one specific suggestion for how the workshop design or facilitation could be improved.
• Give the candidate 5 minutes to explain how they would incorporate this feedback in future workshops and what they might do differently.

Activity #3: Innovation Pipeline Management Simulation

This exercise evaluates the candidate's project management capabilities and decision-making skills when overseeing multiple innovation initiatives with limited resources, a common challenge for Innovation Managers.

Directions for the Company:

• Create a scenario with 5-7 potential innovation projects at different stages of development (concept, prototype, pilot, etc.).
• For each project, provide a brief description, estimated resource requirements, potential impact, and key risks.
• Include constraints such as limited budget, timeline pressures, and competing organizational priorities.
• Provide these materials to the candidate 24 hours before the interview.
• Allocate 45 minutes for this exercise: 30 minutes for the candidate to work through the simulation and 15 minutes for discussion.

Directions for the Candidate:

• Review the portfolio of innovation projects and develop a prioritization framework based on strategic alignment, resource requirements, potential impact, and risk.
• Create a proposed innovation pipeline management plan that includes:
• Which projects to advance, pause, or terminate
• Resource allocation recommendations
• Key milestones and decision points
• Risk mitigation strategies
• Prepare to explain your rationale for these decisions, particularly any difficult trade-offs.
• Be ready to discuss how you would communicate these decisions to stakeholders, especially for projects that weren't prioritized.

Feedback Mechanism:

• Provide feedback on the candidate's prioritization approach and decision-making process.
• Highlight one aspect of their pipeline management plan that was particularly strong.
• Present a new constraint or challenge (e.g., "The CEO has just identified one of your paused projects as a strategic priority") and ask the candidate to revise their plan accordingly.
• Observe how they adapt their thinking and balance competing priorities.

Activity #4: Innovation Pitch and Stakeholder Alignment

This exercise assesses the candidate's communication skills and ability to build support for innovation initiatives across different organizational stakeholders, a crucial competency for successful Innovation Managers.

Directions for the Company:

• Develop a scenario around a specific innovation concept that has potential but faces internal resistance.
• Create profiles for 3-4 stakeholders with different priorities and concerns:
• A finance leader concerned about ROI and resource allocation
• A risk-averse operations executive focused on implementation challenges
• A marketing director worried about brand alignment
• An enthusiastic but impatient product manager
• Provide the innovation concept and stakeholder profiles to the candidate 48 hours in advance.
• Arrange for colleagues to role-play these stakeholders during the exercise.
• Allocate 45 minutes: 15 for preparation, 20 for the role-play, and 10 for feedback.

Directions for the Candidate:

• Review the innovation concept and stakeholder profiles.
• Prepare a compelling pitch for the innovation that addresses potential concerns while highlighting benefits relevant to each stakeholder.
• During the role-play, present your pitch and then engage with each "stakeholder" to address their specific questions and concerns.
• Demonstrate your ability to listen actively, adapt your messaging, find common ground, and build consensus.
• Be prepared to make real-time adjustments to your approach based on stakeholder reactions.

Feedback Mechanism:

• After the role-play, provide feedback on the candidate's communication effectiveness and stakeholder management approach.
• Highlight one particularly effective strategy they used to build alignment.
• Identify one stakeholder whose concerns weren't fully addressed, and give the candidate 5 minutes to develop and present an alternative approach for engaging that stakeholder.
• Observe their receptiveness to feedback and ability to develop new strategies.

Frequently Asked Questions

How should we adapt these exercises for remote interviews?

All four activities can be conducted virtually with minor adjustments. For the Innovation Workshop Facilitation, use a virtual whiteboard tool like Miro or Mural. For the Stakeholder Alignment exercise, conduct the role-play via video conference with clear transitions between stakeholders. Provide additional preparation time to account for potential technology challenges.

Should we use real company challenges or fictional scenarios?

Using real challenges provides more authentic context but requires careful consideration of confidentiality. If using actual company challenges, remove sensitive information and have candidates sign NDAs. Fictional scenarios work well too, especially when designed to test specific competencies while reflecting realistic industry situations.

How do we evaluate candidates consistently across these exercises?

Develop a structured evaluation rubric for each exercise that aligns with the key competencies for your Innovation Manager role. Have the same evaluators assess all candidates using these rubrics. Focus on the process and approach rather than specific outcomes, as candidates won't have full context of your organization.

What if a candidate has limited experience with a particular exercise format?

The goal is to assess underlying competencies, not familiarity with specific formats. Provide clear instructions and emphasize that you're evaluating their approach and thinking. Consider offering a brief "warm-up" question to help candidates get comfortable with the format before the main exercise begins.

How much weight should these exercises carry in our overall evaluation?

These work samples should complement, not replace, other assessment methods. Consider allocating 40-50% of your evaluation weight to these exercises, with the remainder distributed across interviews, reference checks, and other assessments. The relative importance may vary based on your organization's specific needs and the seniority of the role.

Can we customize these exercises for different industries or company sizes?

Absolutely! Tailor the scenarios, challenges, and constraints to reflect your industry dynamics and organizational scale. A startup might focus more on resource constraints and rapid iteration, while an enterprise might emphasize stakeholder alignment and integration with existing systems.

Innovation is the lifeblood of organizational growth and adaptation in today's rapidly changing business environment. By incorporating these practical work samples into your hiring process, you'll gain valuable insights into how candidates actually approach innovation challenges, not just how they talk about them. This deeper understanding will help you identify Innovation Managers who can truly drive meaningful change and create lasting value for your organization.

For more resources to enhance your hiring process, check out Yardstick's suite of AI-powered tools, including our AI Job Description Generator, AI Interview Question Generator, and AI Interview Guide Generator. You can also explore our example job description for Innovation Managers at https://yardstick.team/job-description/innovation-manager for additional insights.

Ready to build a complete interview guide for this role? Sign up for a free Yardstick account today!