Effective Work Sample Exercises for Hiring Information Security Managers

In today's digital landscape, the role of an Information Security Manager has become increasingly critical. These professionals serve as the frontline defenders of an organization's digital assets, responsible for developing comprehensive security strategies, implementing robust controls, and responding effectively to emerging threats. The cost of a poor hiring decision for this role can be catastrophic—potentially leading to data breaches, compliance violations, and significant reputational damage.

Traditional interviews often fail to reveal a candidate's true capabilities in handling real-world security challenges. While resumes and certifications provide some insight into a candidate's knowledge base, they don't demonstrate how effectively candidates can apply that knowledge in practical situations. This is where well-designed work samples become invaluable.

Work samples for Information Security Manager candidates should evaluate both technical expertise and essential soft skills like communication, leadership, and strategic thinking. By observing candidates as they tackle realistic security scenarios, hiring managers can gain deeper insights into their problem-solving approaches, decision-making processes, and ability to balance security requirements with business needs.

The following exercises are designed to assess key competencies required for successful Information Security Managers: incident response capabilities, risk assessment skills, policy development expertise, and the ability to effectively communicate security concepts to diverse audiences. These practical evaluations will help you identify candidates who not only understand security principles but can apply them effectively in your organization's specific context.

Activity #1: Security Incident Response Simulation

This exercise simulates a critical security incident, allowing you to evaluate how candidates respond under pressure, prioritize actions, and communicate during a crisis. Effective incident response requires technical knowledge, clear communication, and strategic thinking—all essential qualities for an Information Security Manager.

Directions for the Company:

• Create a detailed scenario of a security incident (e.g., a ransomware attack, data breach, or insider threat) relevant to your organization's industry.
• Provide the candidate with basic information about your company's infrastructure, including network diagrams, system inventories, and existing security controls.
• Assign 1-2 team members to role-play as stakeholders (e.g., CEO, IT staff, legal counsel) whom the candidate will need to interact with during the simulation.
• Allow 45-60 minutes for the complete exercise, including the initial response and the feedback/improvement portion.
• Prepare a timeline of how the incident unfolds, introducing new information at specific intervals to test the candidate's adaptability.

Directions for the Candidate:

• Review the provided company information and initial incident details.
• Develop and execute an incident response plan, including immediate containment actions, investigation steps, and communication strategies.
• Interact with the role-playing stakeholders to gather information, provide updates, and recommend actions.
• Document key findings and decisions throughout the exercise.
• Prepare a brief summary of next steps and lessons learned once the immediate incident is contained.

Feedback Mechanism:

• After the initial response phase, provide specific feedback on the candidate's strengths (e.g., "Your communication with the executive team was clear and appropriately detailed") and one area for improvement (e.g., "Consider prioritizing containment before extensive investigation in this type of incident").
• Give the candidate 10-15 minutes to adjust their approach based on the feedback and demonstrate how they would handle a similar situation differently.
• Observe how receptive they are to feedback and how effectively they incorporate it into their revised approach.

Activity #2: Security Risk Assessment and Mitigation Planning

This exercise evaluates a candidate's ability to identify, analyze, and prioritize security risks—a fundamental responsibility of an Information Security Manager. It also tests their strategic thinking in developing practical mitigation strategies that balance security needs with business objectives.

Directions for the Company:

• Prepare a case study of a fictional company (or an anonymized version of your own) that includes information about its business operations, IT infrastructure, data assets, and compliance requirements.
• Include some existing security controls and known vulnerabilities in the documentation.
• Provide a template for risk assessment that includes columns for risk identification, impact assessment, likelihood evaluation, and mitigation strategies.
• Allow 60 minutes for the complete exercise.
• Consider including specific business constraints (e.g., limited budget, legacy systems that cannot be replaced) to test the candidate's ability to develop realistic solutions.

Directions for the Candidate:

• Review the provided company information and identify at least 5-7 significant security risks.
• Assess each risk in terms of potential impact and likelihood.
• Prioritize the identified risks based on their overall severity and business impact.
• Develop practical mitigation strategies for the top three risks, considering the provided business constraints.
• Prepare a brief presentation (5-7 minutes) explaining your risk assessment methodology, key findings, and recommended mitigation strategies.

Feedback Mechanism:

• Provide feedback on the candidate's risk identification process and prioritization logic.
• Highlight one strength in their approach (e.g., "Your consideration of regulatory implications was thorough") and one area for improvement (e.g., "Consider quantifying the financial impact of each risk to better justify mitigation investments").
• Allow the candidate 10-15 minutes to refine their top mitigation strategy based on the feedback.
• Evaluate their ability to adapt their recommendations while maintaining a balance between security requirements and business needs.

Activity #3: Security Policy Development and Implementation

This exercise assesses a candidate's knowledge of security best practices, regulatory requirements, and their ability to develop effective security policies. It also evaluates their understanding of how to implement policies in a way that ensures compliance without unduly hindering business operations.

Directions for the Company:

• Select a specific security domain relevant to your organization (e.g., remote access, data classification, third-party vendor management).
• Provide information about your organization's structure, culture, and any relevant compliance requirements (e.g., GDPR, HIPAA, PCI DSS).
• Include details about previous challenges with policy implementation or compliance in your organization.
• Prepare a simple template for policy documentation.
• Allow 45-60 minutes for the complete exercise.

Directions for the Candidate:

• Review the provided information about the organization and its compliance requirements.
• Develop a comprehensive security policy for the specified domain that addresses regulatory requirements while considering the organization's specific context.
• Outline an implementation plan that includes:
• Key stakeholders who need to be involved
• Training and awareness requirements
• Monitoring and enforcement mechanisms
• Metrics for measuring policy effectiveness
• Prepare to discuss potential challenges in implementing the policy and strategies to overcome resistance.

Feedback Mechanism:

• Provide feedback on the policy's comprehensiveness, clarity, and practicality.
• Highlight one strength (e.g., "Your policy effectively addresses all relevant compliance requirements") and one area for improvement (e.g., "Consider adding more specific guidance for exception handling").
• Ask the candidate to revise a specific section of the policy based on your feedback.
• Evaluate their ability to maintain the policy's effectiveness while addressing the feedback.

Activity #4: Security Awareness Training Presentation

This exercise evaluates a candidate's ability to communicate complex security concepts to non-technical audiences—a critical skill for Information Security Managers who must foster a security-conscious culture throughout the organization. It also assesses their creativity in developing engaging training materials.

Directions for the Company:

• Select a relevant security topic that all employees should understand (e.g., phishing awareness, secure remote work practices, data handling procedures).
• Provide information about your organization's employee demographics, previous security incidents, and any existing awareness programs.
• Specify the target audience for the presentation (e.g., all employees, executive team, specific department).
• Allow 60 minutes for preparation and 15 minutes for presentation and feedback.
• Assemble a small panel of evaluators representing different departments to assess the presentation's effectiveness.

Directions for the Candidate:

• Develop a 10-minute security awareness presentation on the assigned topic.
• Create visual aids (slides, diagrams, etc.) to support your presentation.
• Include practical examples and actionable recommendations that are relevant to the specified audience.
• Incorporate interactive elements or engagement strategies to maintain audience interest.
• Be prepared to answer questions about how you would measure the effectiveness of the training.

Feedback Mechanism:

• Provide feedback on the presentation's clarity, engagement level, and appropriateness for the target audience.
• Highlight one strength (e.g., "Your real-world examples made the concepts very relatable") and one area for improvement (e.g., "Consider simplifying the technical terminology for this audience").
• Ask the candidate to revise and deliver a specific portion of their presentation based on the feedback.
• Evaluate their ability to adapt their communication style while maintaining the essential security message.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long should we allocate for these work sample exercises?

Each exercise is designed to take 45-60 minutes, including time for feedback and improvement. If you're incorporating multiple exercises into your interview process, consider spreading them across different interview stages or limiting to the 1-2 most relevant for your organization's needs.

Should we use real company data in these exercises?

While using realistic scenarios is valuable, avoid using actual sensitive company information. Create anonymized or fictional scenarios that mirror your real challenges but don't expose confidential data. This protects your organization while still providing a relevant context for evaluation.

How should we evaluate candidates who have experience in different industries?

Focus on the fundamental security principles and approaches demonstrated rather than industry-specific knowledge. Strong candidates should be able to ask clarifying questions about your industry's unique requirements and adapt their approach accordingly.

Can these exercises be conducted remotely?

Yes, all of these exercises can be adapted for remote interviews using video conferencing and collaborative tools. For the incident response simulation, consider using chat tools to simulate real-time communication. For presentations, use screen sharing capabilities.

How do we ensure consistency when evaluating different candidates?

Develop a standardized scoring rubric for each exercise that outlines specific criteria and performance levels. Have the same evaluation team assess all candidates for a particular role, and conduct a calibration session before beginning interviews to align on expectations.

Should we provide these exercises to candidates in advance?

For some exercises, like the security awareness presentation, providing the topic in advance allows candidates to showcase their best work. For others, like the incident response simulation, the ability to think on their feet is part of what you're evaluating. Consider which approach best tests the skills most critical for your specific role.

In today's complex threat landscape, finding the right Information Security Manager is more crucial than ever. By incorporating these practical work samples into your hiring process, you'll gain deeper insights into candidates' capabilities and identify those who can truly protect your organization's digital assets.

Ready to take your hiring process to the next level? Yardstick offers powerful tools to help you design comprehensive interview guides, generate targeted interview questions, and create customized job descriptions for security roles. Learn more about our AI job description generator, AI interview question generator, and AI interview guide generator. For more information about hiring Information Security Managers, check out our detailed job description.

Build a complete interview guide for this role by signing up for a free Yardstick account here