Effective Work Samples for Evaluating AI Image Generation and Manipulation Skills

AI image generation and manipulation skills have become increasingly valuable across industries, from marketing and design to product development and content creation. As organizations integrate AI-powered visual tools into their workflows, the ability to effectively leverage these technologies has evolved from a specialized niche to an essential competency. However, evaluating a candidate's proficiency in this rapidly evolving field requires more than reviewing a portfolio or discussing theoretical knowledge.

The technical aspects of AI image generation—understanding prompting techniques, model capabilities, image editing workflows, and integration with other tools—form just one dimension of expertise. Equally important are creative vision, problem-solving abilities, and the capacity to adapt to new tools and techniques as they emerge. A candidate might be technically proficient but lack the creative judgment to produce compelling visuals, or they might have an excellent eye for design but struggle with the technical aspects of prompt engineering.

Work samples and practical exercises provide a window into how candidates approach real-world challenges in AI image generation and manipulation. By observing candidates as they plan, execute, and refine image creation tasks, hiring managers can assess both technical skills and creative problem-solving abilities. These exercises reveal how candidates think about visual communication, how they adapt to constraints, and how they leverage AI tools to achieve specific objectives.

The following work samples are designed to evaluate candidates holistically, testing not just their familiarity with current tools but their adaptability, creative thinking, and ability to translate requirements into compelling visual assets. Each exercise simulates realistic scenarios that professionals working with AI image generation encounter regularly, providing a comprehensive assessment of a candidate's capabilities in this dynamic field.

Activity #1: Prompt Engineering Challenge

This activity tests a candidate's ability to craft effective prompts for AI image generation tools. Prompt engineering is a fundamental skill that combines technical knowledge of how AI models interpret language with creative vision and problem-solving. A skilled prompt engineer can efficiently guide AI tools to produce images that match specific requirements, saving time and resources while achieving high-quality results.

Directions for the Company:

• Prepare a brief for a fictional product or campaign that requires several visual assets.
• The brief should include specific requirements such as brand guidelines, target audience, and intended use cases.
• Provide access to an AI image generation tool (e.g., DALL-E, Midjourney, Stable Diffusion) or allow candidates to use their preferred tool.
• Allocate 30-45 minutes for this exercise.
• Have a list of common challenges ready to introduce midway through the exercise (e.g., "The client now wants the image to include their logo" or "The image needs to work in both landscape and portrait orientations").

Directions for the Candidate:

• Review the brief and identify key visual elements needed to fulfill the requirements.
• Create 3-5 different prompts designed to generate images that meet the brief's specifications.
• Generate images using these prompts and select the most successful results.
• Document your prompt strategy, explaining your choices and how you approached translating the brief into effective prompts.
• Be prepared to modify your approach based on feedback or changing requirements.

Feedback Mechanism:

• After reviewing the candidate's initial results, provide specific feedback on one aspect that worked well (e.g., "Your use of descriptive adjectives produced a consistent style") and one area for improvement (e.g., "The composition could be more balanced to highlight the product").
• Give the candidate 10-15 minutes to refine their prompts based on this feedback and generate new images.
• Observe how they incorporate the feedback and whether their revised approach produces better results.

Activity #2: Image Manipulation and Enhancement

This exercise evaluates a candidate's technical skills in post-processing and enhancing AI-generated images. While initial generation is important, the ability to refine, combine, and manipulate images is crucial for producing professional-quality assets. This activity tests proficiency with image editing tools and techniques specific to working with AI-generated content.

Directions for the Company:

• Prepare 2-3 AI-generated images that have common issues (e.g., inconsistent anatomy, awkward compositions, unrealistic lighting).
• Provide access to image editing software (Adobe Photoshop, GIMP, or similar tools).
• Include a brief outlining what needs to be improved or changed in each image.
• Allocate 45-60 minutes for this exercise.
• Prepare reference images or examples of the desired outcome to share with the candidate.

Directions for the Candidate:

• Review the provided AI-generated images and identify areas that need improvement.
• Use image editing tools to enhance, correct, or modify the images according to the brief.
• Document your workflow and the techniques you used to address each issue.
• Save before and after versions to demonstrate the changes made.
• Be prepared to explain your approach and why you chose specific techniques.

Feedback Mechanism:

• Provide feedback on one technical aspect the candidate handled well and one area where their technique could be improved.
• Ask the candidate to focus on the area for improvement and demonstrate how they would approach it differently.
• Allow 15 minutes for the candidate to implement this revised approach on a portion of the image.
• Evaluate both their technical skills and their receptiveness to feedback.

Activity #3: Multi-Image Project Planning

This activity assesses a candidate's ability to plan and manage complex projects involving multiple AI-generated images. Success in AI image generation often depends on strategic planning, resource management, and a systematic approach to achieving consistent results across multiple assets. This exercise reveals how candidates think about project scope, consistency, and efficiency.

Directions for the Company:

• Create a brief for a project requiring 8-10 related images (e.g., a product line, a website, or a marketing campaign).
• Include specific requirements for visual consistency, style guidelines, and technical specifications.
• Provide a template for the project plan or allow candidates to use their preferred format.
• Allocate 45-60 minutes for this planning exercise.
• Prepare questions to probe the candidate's reasoning behind their approach.

Directions for the Candidate:

• Develop a comprehensive project plan for creating the required images using AI generation tools.
• Your plan should include:
• A strategy for maintaining visual consistency across all images
• Sample prompts for 2-3 of the images
• A workflow showing the steps from initial generation to final delivery
• Potential challenges and how you would address them
• Time and resource estimates
• Be prepared to explain how you would adapt your plan if certain images prove difficult to generate.

Feedback Mechanism:

• Provide feedback on one strength of the candidate's plan and one area that could be more robust or detailed.
• Ask the candidate to revise the identified area of their plan, incorporating your feedback.
• Allow 15 minutes for this revision.
• Evaluate both the quality of their initial plan and how effectively they incorporated feedback into their revision.

Activity #4: Creative Problem-Solving with AI Limitations

This exercise tests a candidate's ability to work around the inherent limitations of AI image generation tools. Understanding these constraints and developing creative solutions is essential for professional work with these technologies. This activity reveals how candidates approach technical challenges and leverage multiple techniques to achieve desired results.

Directions for the Company:

• Prepare a brief for an image that includes elements known to be challenging for AI tools (e.g., specific text, complex hands, particular brand elements, or architectural accuracy).
• Provide access to both AI generation tools and image editing software.
• Include examples of similar challenges and how they might be addressed.
• Allocate 60 minutes for this exercise.
• Be prepared to discuss alternative approaches if the candidate struggles with particular aspects.

Directions for the Candidate:

• Review the brief and identify which elements will be challenging for AI tools to generate accurately.
• Develop a strategy that combines AI generation, prompt engineering, and post-processing techniques to overcome these limitations.
• Execute your strategy to create an image that meets the requirements despite the inherent challenges.
• Document your process, including:
• How you identified the limitations
• The techniques you used to address each challenge
• Any compromises or alternative approaches you considered
• Be prepared to explain your reasoning and demonstrate your techniques.

Feedback Mechanism:

• Provide feedback on one innovative solution the candidate developed and one area where their approach could be more efficient or effective.
• Ask the candidate to demonstrate an alternative approach to the area identified for improvement.
• Allow 15-20 minutes for the candidate to implement this alternative approach.
• Evaluate their problem-solving creativity, technical knowledge of AI limitations, and ability to adapt their approach.

Frequently Asked Questions

How should we evaluate candidates who use different AI image generation tools than we do?

Focus on evaluating the candidate's process, reasoning, and results rather than their familiarity with specific tools. The fundamental skills of prompt engineering, visual thinking, and problem-solving transfer across platforms. If your organization uses specific tools, you can assess adaptability by asking candidates how they would modify their approach for your preferred platform.

What if we don't have access to premium AI image generation tools for the interview process?

Many AI image generation tools offer free tiers or trial versions that are sufficient for evaluation purposes. Alternatively, you can structure the exercises to focus more on planning, prompt creation, and post-processing strategies, with less emphasis on generating multiple iterations during the interview itself. Candidates can also be invited to use their own tool access if available.

How do we fairly evaluate candidates with varying levels of experience with AI image generation?

Establish clear evaluation criteria that consider both technical proficiency and potential for growth. For less experienced candidates, place greater emphasis on their learning approach, creative problem-solving, and how quickly they adapt to feedback. For more experienced candidates, expectations should be higher regarding efficiency, sophisticated techniques, and the quality of their results.

Should candidates be allowed to use reference materials or look up information during these exercises?

Yes, allowing access to reference materials more accurately reflects real-world working conditions. Professional AI image creators regularly consult documentation, examples, and resources. This approach also helps evaluate how candidates research solutions and apply new information, which is valuable in a rapidly evolving field.

How can we ensure these exercises don't take too much time in our interview process?

You can select 1-2 exercises most relevant to your specific needs rather than conducting all four. Another approach is to ask candidates to complete a simplified version of one exercise before the interview, then use the interview time to discuss their process and have them make revisions based on feedback.

What if a candidate produces technically proficient but aesthetically weak images, or vice versa?

This outcome provides valuable information about the candidate's strengths and development areas. Consider whether your role requires more technical expertise or creative vision, and whether you have team members who can complement the candidate's skills. The feedback portions of these exercises also reveal how quickly candidates can improve in their weaker areas.

AI image generation and manipulation skills continue to grow in importance as these technologies become more integrated into creative and production workflows. By implementing structured work samples like those outlined above, organizations can make more informed hiring decisions based on demonstrated abilities rather than self-reported expertise. These exercises provide insight into not just technical proficiency, but also creative thinking, problem-solving approaches, and adaptability—all crucial qualities in this rapidly evolving field.

For more resources to optimize your hiring process, explore Yardstick's suite of AI-powered tools, including our AI Job Descriptions generator, AI Interview Question Generator, and AI Interview Guide Generator. These tools can help you build comprehensive evaluation frameworks for any role, ensuring you identify candidates with the right mix of skills and potential.

Ready to build a complete interview guide for evaluating AI image generation skills? Sign up for a free Yardstick account today!