Effective Work Samples for Hiring a Top Benefits Manager

The Benefits Manager role is critical to an organization's ability to attract and retain top talent while managing costs effectively. This position requires a unique blend of analytical skills, regulatory knowledge, communication abilities, and strategic thinking. A strong Benefits Manager can significantly impact employee satisfaction, organizational culture, and the company's bottom line.

Traditional interviews often fail to reveal a candidate's true capabilities in designing and managing complex benefits programs. While candidates may articulate their knowledge well in conversation, their practical skills in analyzing data, solving problems, and communicating benefits information effectively are better assessed through hands-on exercises.

Work samples provide a window into how candidates approach real-world scenarios they'll face in the role. For Benefits Manager candidates, these exercises can demonstrate their ability to balance employee needs with budget constraints, navigate compliance requirements, and present complex information clearly to various stakeholders.

By incorporating the following work samples into your interview process, you'll gain deeper insights into each candidate's capabilities and fit for your organization. These exercises simulate the actual challenges a Benefits Manager faces, allowing you to make more informed hiring decisions based on demonstrated skills rather than self-reported experience.

Activity #1: Benefits Program Analysis and Recommendation

This exercise evaluates the candidate's ability to analyze benefits data, identify opportunities for improvement, and make strategic recommendations that balance employee needs with budget considerations. These analytical and strategic skills are fundamental to the Benefits Manager role, as they'll regularly need to evaluate program effectiveness and propose changes.

Directions for the Company:

• Prepare a sanitized dataset showing current benefits utilization rates, costs, and basic employee demographic information.
• Include information about the company's budget constraints and strategic priorities.
• Allow candidates 45-60 minutes to review the materials and prepare their recommendations.
• Provide access to a computer with Excel or similar software for analysis.
• Consider including employee satisfaction survey results related to benefits.

Directions for the Candidate:

• Review the provided benefits data and company information.
• Identify 2-3 key areas where the benefits program could be improved.
• Prepare a brief presentation (5-7 minutes) outlining:
• Your analysis of the current benefits program strengths and weaknesses
• Specific recommendations for changes or additions to the program
• Estimated cost implications and potential ROI for your recommendations
• Implementation considerations and timeline

Feedback Mechanism:

• After the presentation, provide feedback on one aspect the candidate analyzed well and one area where their analysis could be more comprehensive.
• Ask the candidate to spend 5 minutes refining one of their recommendations based on the feedback.
• Observe how they incorporate the feedback and adjust their thinking.

Activity #2: Benefits Communication Plan

This exercise assesses the candidate's ability to translate complex benefits information into clear, engaging communications for employees. Effective communication is essential for ensuring employees understand and utilize their benefits appropriately, which directly impacts program effectiveness and employee satisfaction.

Directions for the Company:

• Provide details about a fictional new benefit being added to the company's program (e.g., a new wellness program, mental health benefit, or financial planning resource).
• Include basic information about the company's employee demographics and communication channels.
• Allow 30-45 minutes for the candidate to develop their communication plan.
• Provide access to a computer with word processing software.

Directions for the Candidate:

• Create a comprehensive communication plan for rolling out the new benefit to employees.
• Your plan should include:
• Key messaging points that explain the benefit and its value
• A timeline for communications before, during, and after implementation
• Different communication methods to reach various employee groups
• A sample email announcement or flyer introducing the benefit
• Strategies for measuring employee understanding and engagement

Feedback Mechanism:

• Provide feedback on one strength of their communication approach and one area that could be improved.
• Ask the candidate to revise their sample announcement based on your feedback.
• Evaluate their ability to incorporate feedback while maintaining clarity and engagement in their communication.

Activity #3: Compliance Challenge Scenario

This exercise evaluates the candidate's knowledge of benefits-related regulations and their problem-solving skills when facing compliance challenges. A Benefits Manager must ensure all programs adhere to relevant laws and regulations, making this a critical skill for the role.

Directions for the Company:

• Create a scenario describing a potential compliance issue related to benefits (e.g., ACA reporting discrepancy, ERISA violation concern, or HIPAA privacy question).
• Include relevant background information about the company's benefits structure.
• Allow 30-45 minutes for the candidate to review and respond to the scenario.
• Consider having a benefits compliance expert participate in evaluating responses.

Directions for the Candidate:

• Review the compliance scenario provided.
• Prepare a written response that includes:
• Your assessment of the compliance issue and potential risks
• Recommended immediate actions to address the situation
• Long-term preventive measures to avoid similar issues
• Suggestions for communicating with affected stakeholders
• Resources or external partners you might consult

Feedback Mechanism:

• Provide feedback on one aspect of their response that demonstrated strong compliance knowledge and one area where their approach could be enhanced.
• Ask the candidate to verbally explain how they would modify their approach based on your feedback.
• Evaluate their ability to adapt their thinking while maintaining regulatory compliance.

Activity #4: Vendor Negotiation Role Play

This exercise assesses the candidate's ability to negotiate effectively with benefits vendors, a crucial skill for managing costs while maintaining quality benefits offerings. The role play format reveals how candidates think on their feet and advocate for the organization's interests.

Directions for the Company:

• Prepare a scenario involving a renewal negotiation with a benefits provider (e.g., health insurance, 401(k) administrator, or wellness program vendor).
• Include details about current costs, service issues, and company priorities.
• Assign a team member to play the role of the vendor representative.
• Allow the candidate 15 minutes to review the materials before the 20-minute role play.
• Brief the person playing the vendor on typical vendor positions and negotiation tactics.

Directions for the Candidate:

• Review the information provided about the current vendor relationship and company priorities.
• Prepare for a negotiation meeting with the vendor representative.
• During the role play:
• Discuss service issues and potential improvements
• Negotiate pricing for the upcoming contract period
• Explore additional services or features that might benefit employees
• Work toward a mutually beneficial agreement
• Be prepared to make decisions about trade-offs between cost and services

Feedback Mechanism:

• Provide feedback on one effective negotiation tactic the candidate used and one area where their approach could be strengthened.
• Give the candidate an opportunity to explain how they would adjust their negotiation strategy based on the feedback.
• Evaluate their ability to incorporate feedback while maintaining a collaborative yet assertive negotiation stance.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long should we allocate for these work samples in our interview process?

Each exercise requires approximately 1-1.5 hours including preparation, execution, and feedback. Consider spreading them across different interview stages or selecting the 2-3 most relevant to your specific needs if time is limited.

Should we provide these exercises to candidates in advance?

For the Benefits Program Analysis and Communication Plan exercises, providing the scenario 24-48 hours in advance can yield more thoughtful responses. The Compliance Challenge and Vendor Negotiation are better conducted with minimal advance notice to assess how candidates think on their feet.

How should we evaluate candidates who have experience with different benefits systems than what our company uses?

Focus on the candidate's analytical approach, problem-solving process, and communication skills rather than specific knowledge of your systems. Strong candidates will ask clarifying questions and adapt their approach to your context.

What if a candidate identifies issues with our current benefits approach during these exercises?

This can actually be valuable insight! Consider it a positive sign if a candidate can respectfully highlight improvement opportunities you hadn't considered. Their fresh perspective might be exactly what your benefits program needs.

Should we customize these exercises for different levels of Benefits Manager positions?

Yes, adjust the complexity based on the seniority of the role. For a senior position, emphasize strategic elements and executive communication. For more junior roles, focus more on execution, compliance knowledge, and direct employee communication.

How do we ensure these exercises don't create an undue burden on candidates?

Be transparent about the time commitment required and consider offering flexibility in scheduling. If possible, compensate candidates for extensive time investments, particularly for the more complex analysis exercise.

The right Benefits Manager can transform your organization's approach to employee benefits, creating programs that enhance recruitment, retention, and employee wellbeing while managing costs effectively. By incorporating these work samples into your hiring process, you'll identify candidates who not only understand benefits theory but can execute effectively in real-world scenarios.

For more resources to improve your hiring process, explore Yardstick's tools for creating AI-powered job descriptions, interview questions, and comprehensive interview guides.

Ready to build a complete interview guide for your Benefits Manager role? Sign up for a free Yardstick account today!