Essential Work Samples for Hiring Top Digital Marketing Managers

Digital Marketing Managers serve as the strategic architects behind a company's online presence and digital growth initiatives. They blend creativity with analytical thinking to drive brand awareness, lead generation, and customer acquisition across multiple digital channels. Finding the right person for this role is critical, as they'll be responsible for allocating significant marketing budgets and shaping how your brand appears in the digital landscape.

Traditional interviews often fail to reveal a candidate's true capabilities in digital marketing. While candidates may eloquently discuss their past campaigns or technical knowledge, this doesn't necessarily translate to their ability to execute effectively in your specific business context. Work samples provide a window into how candidates approach real marketing challenges, analyze data, and develop actionable strategies.

The exercises outlined below are designed to evaluate candidates on the core competencies required for digital marketing success: strategic thinking, analytical skills, creative problem-solving, and tactical execution. By observing candidates as they work through these scenarios, you'll gain valuable insights into their thought processes, technical proficiency, and ability to drive measurable results.

Implementing these work samples will significantly improve your hiring process by moving beyond resume claims and rehearsed interview answers. You'll be able to differentiate between candidates who merely talk about digital marketing best practices and those who can actually implement them effectively. This approach not only helps identify top talent but also gives candidates a realistic preview of the role, ensuring better alignment and reducing early turnover.

Activity #1: Digital Campaign Strategy Development

This exercise evaluates a candidate's ability to develop a comprehensive digital marketing strategy based on business objectives, target audience insights, and competitive analysis. Strategic planning is fundamental to the Digital Marketing Manager role, as it requires synthesizing multiple data points into a cohesive plan that drives measurable results.

Directions for the Company:

• Provide the candidate with a brief that includes: company background, product/service information, target audience demographics, business objectives (e.g., increase lead generation by 20%), and budget constraints.
• Include basic competitive information and any current marketing performance metrics.
• Allow candidates 24-48 hours to prepare their strategy before the interview.
• Allocate 20 minutes for presentation and 10 minutes for questions.
• Resources to provide: Brand guidelines, sample past campaign performance data, audience personas, and marketing objectives document.

Directions for the Candidate:

• Develop a 90-day digital marketing strategy that addresses the business objectives provided.
• Include channel selection with rationale, budget allocation, content strategy, and KPIs for measuring success.
• Prepare a brief presentation (5-7 slides) outlining your strategy, including timeline and expected outcomes.
• Be prepared to explain your reasoning and answer questions about your strategic choices.
• Focus on demonstrating how your approach will achieve the stated business objectives.

Feedback Mechanism:

• After the presentation, provide specific feedback on one strategic element the candidate executed well and one area that could be improved.
• Ask the candidate to revise their channel allocation or budget distribution based on the feedback, giving them 5-10 minutes to make adjustments and explain their revised approach.
• Observe how receptive they are to feedback and how effectively they incorporate it into their strategy.

Activity #2: Analytics Problem-Solving Exercise

This exercise tests a candidate's ability to analyze marketing data, identify trends and issues, and develop data-driven recommendations. A successful Digital Marketing Manager must be able to interpret complex analytics to optimize campaign performance and justify marketing investments.

Directions for the Company:

• Prepare a dataset that includes web traffic, conversion rates, campaign performance metrics, and customer acquisition costs across multiple channels.
• Intentionally include some anomalies or performance issues that need to be identified.
• Provide access to the data in a spreadsheet or dashboard format.
• Allow 30-45 minutes for the candidate to analyze the data and prepare recommendations.
• Resources to provide: Spreadsheet with marketing performance data, business context document, and current marketing goals.

Directions for the Candidate:

• Review the provided marketing performance data across all channels.
• Identify key trends, opportunities, and potential issues in the current marketing performance.
• Prepare 3-5 specific, data-backed recommendations to improve performance.
• Be ready to explain which metrics you prioritized and why.
• Create a simple visualization or summary that highlights your key findings.
• Suggest how you would implement an A/B test to validate one of your recommendations.

Feedback Mechanism:

• Provide feedback on the candidate's analytical approach, highlighting one strength in their methodology and one area where their analysis could be more comprehensive.
• Ask the candidate to refine one of their recommendations based on an additional constraint or business consideration you introduce.
• Give them 5-10 minutes to adjust their recommendation and explain how this new information impacts their thinking.

Activity #3: Content and Creative Brief Development

This exercise assesses a candidate's ability to translate marketing objectives into clear creative direction for content creators and designers. Effective communication of brand voice, messaging, and creative requirements is essential for managing successful digital marketing campaigns.

Directions for the Company:

• Provide information about a new product or service launch that requires digital marketing content.
• Include target audience information, key selling points, and overall campaign objectives.
• Specify that content will be needed across multiple channels (social media, email, website, etc.).
• Allow 30-45 minutes for the candidate to develop their brief.
• Resources to provide: Product/service information sheet, brand guidelines, target audience personas, and examples of previous successful content.

Directions for the Candidate:

• Create a comprehensive creative brief for a multi-channel digital marketing campaign for the product/service provided.
• Include target audience insights, key messaging points, tone and style guidelines, and channel-specific requirements.
• Outline content types needed (videos, blog posts, social media posts, etc.) with specific direction for each.
• Develop a content calendar showing the recommended sequence and timing of content deployment.
• Explain how each content piece supports the customer journey and contributes to campaign objectives.
• Include notes on how content performance should be measured.

Feedback Mechanism:

• Provide feedback on one aspect of the brief that effectively communicates creative direction and one element that needs more clarity or strategic alignment.
• Ask the candidate to revise the brief for one specific channel based on your feedback.
• Give them 10 minutes to make the adjustments and explain their reasoning for the changes.
• Evaluate their ability to maintain brand consistency while adapting to channel-specific requirements.

Activity #4: Digital Marketing Budget Optimization

This exercise evaluates a candidate's ability to allocate marketing resources effectively and optimize budget distribution based on performance data. Budget management is a critical skill for Digital Marketing Managers who must maximize ROI across multiple channels and initiatives.

Directions for the Company:

• Provide a scenario with a fixed marketing budget (e.g., $50,000 quarterly) and historical performance data across channels (paid search, social media, email, content, etc.).
• Include current cost metrics (CPC, CPL, CAC) for each channel and business objectives for the coming quarter.
• Introduce a complication, such as a significant increase in competition on one channel or a new platform to consider.
• Allow 30-45 minutes for the exercise.
• Resources to provide: Previous quarter's budget allocation spreadsheet, channel performance metrics, and business objectives document.

Directions for the Candidate:

• Review the historical performance data and current business objectives.
• Create a proposed budget allocation for the coming quarter across all available channels.
• Provide clear rationale for any significant changes from the previous quarter's allocation.
• Identify opportunities to improve efficiency and reduce customer acquisition costs.
• Develop a contingency plan for adjusting the budget mid-quarter if certain channels underperform.
• Suggest 2-3 experiments or new initiatives to test, with clear KPIs for measuring their success.

Feedback Mechanism:

• Provide feedback on the candidate's budget allocation strategy, highlighting one particularly effective decision and one area where their approach could be optimized.
• Present a hypothetical scenario where one channel is significantly underperforming two weeks into the quarter.
• Ask the candidate to explain how they would reallocate resources in response to this development.
• Give them 10 minutes to adjust their budget plan and explain their reallocation strategy.
• Evaluate their agility in responding to performance data and their ability to make data-driven decisions under pressure.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long should we allow candidates to complete these work samples?

For Activities #1 and #3, we recommend giving candidates 24-48 hours of preparation time before the interview. For Activities #2 and #4, which are more analytical in nature, allocate 30-45 minutes during the interview process. The feedback and revision portions should take an additional 10-15 minutes per activity.

Should we use real company data for these exercises?

While using real data provides the most authentic assessment, it's important to protect sensitive information. Consider creating modified datasets based on actual performance but with altered numbers. Alternatively, you can create realistic fictional data that reflects typical patterns in your industry.

What if a candidate doesn't have experience with our specific marketing tools?

Focus on evaluating the candidate's approach and strategic thinking rather than their proficiency with specific tools. Provide data in accessible formats like spreadsheets rather than requiring them to navigate unfamiliar platforms. The core marketing principles and analytical skills are more important than tool-specific knowledge, which can be learned.

How should we weight these exercises compared to traditional interviews?

These work samples should account for approximately 50-60% of your evaluation, with traditional interviews and reference checks making up the remainder. The work samples provide objective evidence of capabilities, while interviews help assess cultural fit and communication skills.

Should we compensate candidates for completing these exercises?

For exercises requiring significant preparation time (like Activity #1), consider offering compensation, especially for senior roles or if candidates have progressed to final interview stages. This demonstrates respect for their time and expertise while ensuring you receive thoughtful, quality work.

Can these exercises be adapted for remote hiring processes?

Yes, all of these exercises can be conducted virtually. Use video conferencing platforms for presentations and discussions, and collaborative tools like Google Sheets or Miro for real-time work on analytics or budget exercises. Ensure candidates have clear instructions and access to all necessary resources before the virtual session.

Finding the right Digital Marketing Manager can transform your company's digital presence and drive significant business growth. By incorporating these work samples into your hiring process, you'll be able to identify candidates who not only understand digital marketing principles but can apply them effectively in real-world scenarios. This approach helps ensure you hire someone who can truly deliver results, not just someone who interviews well.

For more resources to improve your hiring process, check out Yardstick's AI Job Descriptions, AI Interview Question Generator, and AI Interview Guide Generator. These tools can help you create comprehensive job descriptions and interview guides tailored to your specific needs.

Ready to build a complete interview guide for this Digital Marketing Manager role? Sign up for a free Yardstick account today!