Interview Guide for

Senior Director Of Customer Success

This comprehensive interview guide is designed to help you effectively evaluate candidates for the Senior Director of Customer Success role. It provides a structured approach to assess candidates' skills, experience, and potential to drive customer growth and satisfaction initiatives in your organization.

The guide includes a series of interviews and a work sample exercise, each tailored to evaluate specific aspects of the candidate's qualifications and fit for the role. By following this guide, you'll be able to make more informed hiring decisions and identify candidates who are best suited to lead your customer success efforts.

How to Use This Guide

Familiarize yourself with the entire guide before beginning the interview process.
Conduct each interview in the order presented, starting with the Screening Interview and progressing through the more in-depth assessments.
Use the provided questions and follow-up probes to gather comprehensive information about the candidate's experience and capabilities.
Complete the scorecards after each interview to objectively evaluate the candidate's performance.
Pay attention to the guidance provided for each question to ensure you're gathering the most relevant information.
Adapt the questions as needed to fit your specific organizational context, but maintain consistency across all candidates.
Use the work sample exercise to assess the candidate's practical skills and strategic thinking abilities.
After completing all interviews and exercises, conduct a thorough debrief with the hiring team to discuss findings and make a final decision.

For additional ideas on interview questions for this role, you can explore our comprehensive list of customer success interview questions. This resource can help you customize the interview process to better align with your organization's specific needs and culture.

Remember, the key to effective interviewing is consistency and objectivity. By following this guide and using the provided scorecards, you'll be better equipped to identify the best candidate to lead your customer success initiatives and drive business growth.

Job Description

🎯 Role Overview

[Company] is seeking a Senior Director of Customer Success to lead our customer growth and satisfaction initiatives. This pivotal role will own the customer journey, drive product adoption, and ensure customers realize maximum value from our solutions.

💼 Key Responsibilities

Drive Customer Success Outcomes

Deliver measurable ROI to customers from our products
Influence future customer lifetime value through higher product adoption, satisfaction, and overall health scores
Drive new business growth through customer advocacy and referrals

Define and Optimize Customer Lifecycle

Map the customer journey and develop key listening points
Standardize interventions for each stage of the journey
Define customer segmentation strategies
Identify opportunities for continuous improvement

Lead and Develop Teams

Measure and improve the effectiveness of Customer Success, Professional Services, and Customer Enablement teams
Become the Voice of the Customer within the organization
Drive cross-functional initiatives to improve customer engagement and adoption

🌟 What Success Looks Like

Consistently improving customer satisfaction metrics (NPS, CSAT)
Increasing product adoption rates across the customer base
Growing customer lifetime value and reducing churn
Developing a high-performing, customer-centric team

📊 Qualifications

Required Experience

10+ years of experience leading customer-oriented teams
Proven track record of driving customer success in a B2B SaaS environment
Experience working with enterprise-level clients and C-suite executives
Strong understanding of business & technology landscapes

Key Skills

Exceptional leadership and team development abilities
Strong negotiation and consultative skills
Ability to understand and articulate complex customer needs
Experience working effectively with remote teams
Outstanding communication and presentation skills

Nice-to-Have

PMP certification
Experience with enterprise software implementations
Knowledge of professional services and support processes

📍 Location

[Location] with potential for remote work

💰 Compensation

[Salary Range + Benefits Overview]

Ideal Candidate Profile (Internal)

Role Overview

This role requires a strategic leader who can balance high-level customer success strategy with hands-on team leadership. The ideal candidate will have a proven track record of scaling customer success operations in a high-growth environment.

Essential Behavioral Competencies

Strategic Thinking
Customer Centricity
Change Management
Cross-functional Leadership
Data-driven Decision Making

Example Goals for Role

Increase overall Net Revenue Retention (NRR) to 120% within the first year
Reduce customer churn rate by 25% through improved onboarding and adoption processes
Implement a customer health scoring system with 90% accuracy in predicting churn risk
Achieve a Customer Satisfaction (CSAT) score of 95% or higher
Develop and launch two new customer success programs that demonstrably increase product adoption

Ideal Candidate Profile

Proven experience scaling customer success operations in a high-growth SaaS company
Strong analytical skills with the ability to translate data into actionable insights
Track record of developing and mentoring high-performing teams
Experience implementing and optimizing customer success technologies (e.g., Gainsight, Totango)
Excellent executive presence and ability to influence senior stakeholders
Passionate about customer advocacy and driving measurable business outcomes
[Industry-specific experience, if relevant]
Located in or willing to relocate to [location]
Alignment with [Company]'s core values and culture

Screening Interview

Directions for the Interviewer

This initial screening interview is crucial for quickly assessing if a candidate should move forward in the process. Focus on work eligibility, cultural fit, performance history, and key skills. Getting details on past performance early is essential. Ask all candidates the same questions to ensure fair comparisons.

Directions to Share with Candidate

"I'll be asking you some initial questions about your background and experience to determine fit for our Senior Director of Customer Success role. Please provide concise but thorough answers. Do you have any questions before we begin?"

Interview Questions

Are you legally authorized to work in [country] without sponsorship?

Guidance for Interviewer:Areas to Cover:

Confirm work eligibility status
Any visa or work permit requirements

Possible Follow-up Questions:

When does your current work authorization expire?
Are there any restrictions on your ability to work?

Tell me about your most recent customer success leadership role and the size of the team you managed.

Guidance for Interviewer:Areas to Cover:

Scope of leadership responsibility
Team structure and size
Key performance metrics

Possible Follow-up Questions:

What was your team's Net Revenue Retention (NRR) in that role?
How did you measure and improve team performance?
What was your biggest leadership challenge and how did you overcome it?

Walk me through your experience with implementing or optimizing customer success technologies.

Guidance for Interviewer:Areas to Cover:

Specific technologies used (e.g., Gainsight, Totango)
Implementation process and challenges
Measurable impact on operations

Possible Follow-up Questions:

How did you ensure adoption of the new technology across your team?
What key metrics did you track and improve using these tools?
How did you integrate these tools with other systems in your tech stack?

Describe a situation where you had to influence senior stakeholders to drive a customer success initiative.

Guidance for Interviewer:Areas to Cover:

Nature of the initiative
Stakeholders involved
Approach to influence and persuasion
Outcome and impact

Possible Follow-up Questions:

How did you build your business case?
What objections did you face and how did you overcome them?
How did you measure the success of this initiative?

Tell me about a time when you had to make a data-driven decision to improve customer outcomes.

Guidance for Interviewer:Areas to Cover:

Data sources and analysis process
Decision-making framework
Implementation of decision
Results and lessons learned

Possible Follow-up Questions:

How did you ensure the data you were using was reliable?
What tools or techniques did you use for your analysis?
How did you communicate your findings and recommendations to your team and leadership?

How do you approach developing and mentoring high-performing teams?

Guidance for Interviewer:Areas to Cover:

Leadership philosophy
Specific development strategies
Performance management approach
Success stories

Possible Follow-up Questions:

Can you give an example of how you've helped a team member grow into a leadership role?
How do you handle underperforming team members?
What's your approach to fostering a culture of continuous learning?

What questions do you have about the role or our company?

Guidance for Interviewer:Areas to Cover:

Depth of candidate research
Genuine interest in role
Thoughtfulness of questions

Possible Follow-up Questions:

What excites you most about potentially joining our team?
Is there anything that gives you hesitation about the role?

Interview Scorecard

Leadership Experience

0: Not Enough Information Gathered to Evaluate
1: Limited leadership experience in customer success
2: Some leadership experience, but not at the scale required
3: Solid leadership experience aligned with role requirements
4: Extensive leadership experience exceeding role requirements

Customer Success Technology Expertise

0: Not Enough Information Gathered to Evaluate
1: Limited experience with customer success technologies
2: Basic experience with some relevant technologies
3: Strong experience implementing and optimizing key CS technologies
4: Expert-level knowledge and innovative use of CS technologies

Stakeholder Influence

0: Not Enough Information Gathered to Evaluate
1: Struggles to influence senior stakeholders
2: Can influence peers but limited experience with executives
3: Demonstrated ability to influence senior stakeholders effectively
4: Exceptional track record of influencing at the highest levels

Data-Driven Decision Making

0: Not Enough Information Gathered to Evaluate
1: Relies primarily on intuition rather than data
2: Uses data but struggles to draw meaningful insights
3: Effectively uses data to drive decisions and improve outcomes
4: Sophisticated use of data analytics to drive strategic decisions

Team Development

0: Not Enough Information Gathered to Evaluate
1: Limited focus on team development
2: Basic approach to team development
3: Strong track record of developing high-performing teams
4: Innovative approaches to team development with exceptional results

Goal: Increase overall Net Revenue Retention (NRR) to 120% within the first year

0: Not Enough Information Gathered to Evaluate
1: Unlikely to Achieve Goal
2: Likely to Partially Achieve Goal
3: Likely to Achieve Goal
4: Likely to Exceed Goal

Goal: Reduce customer churn rate by 25% through improved onboarding and adoption processes

0: Not Enough Information Gathered to Evaluate
1: Unlikely to Achieve Goal
2: Likely to Partially Achieve Goal
3: Likely to Achieve Goal
4: Likely to Exceed Goal

Overall Recommendation

1: Strong No Hire
2: No Hire
3: Hire
4: Strong Hire

Work Sample: Customer Success Strategy Presentation

Directions for the Interviewer

This work sample assesses the candidate's ability to develop and present a strategic customer success plan. Provide the candidate with background information on a hypothetical customer scenario and your product/service. Evaluate their strategic thinking, customer-centricity, and ability to articulate a clear plan.

Best practices:

Give the candidate 48 hours to prepare before the presentation
Limit the presentation to 20 minutes, followed by 10 minutes of Q&A
Take notes on specific ideas, strategies, and how they align with your company's goals
Provide a brief opportunity for the candidate to self-reflect after the exercise

Directions to Share with Candidate

"For this exercise, you'll develop and present a strategic customer success plan for a hypothetical enterprise customer using our [product/service]. You'll have 48 hours to prepare a 20-minute presentation, followed by 10 minutes of Q&A. Your goal is to outline a 12-month plan to drive adoption, reduce churn risk, and increase the customer's lifetime value. We'll provide you with background information on the customer and our product. Do you have any questions?"

Provide the candidate with:

Brief overview of your product/service
Hypothetical customer profile, including current usage and pain points
Key company goals and metrics
Any other relevant background information

Interview Scorecard

Strategic Thinking

0: Not Enough Information Gathered to Evaluate
1: Plan lacks coherent strategy or alignment with goals
2: Basic strategy with some alignment to goals
3: Well-developed strategy clearly aligned with company and customer goals
4: Innovative, comprehensive strategy that exceeds expectations

Customer-Centricity

0: Not Enough Information Gathered to Evaluate
1: Minimal focus on customer needs or outcomes
2: Basic consideration of customer needs
3: Strong focus on customer outcomes and value creation
4: Exceptional understanding of customer needs with innovative solutions

Data-Driven Approach

0: Not Enough Information Gathered to Evaluate
1: Minimal use of data to support strategy
2: Basic use of data, but limited insights
3: Effective use of data to drive strategy and decisions
4: Sophisticated use of data with predictive insights

Actionable Implementation Plan

0: Not Enough Information Gathered to Evaluate
1: Vague or unrealistic implementation plan
2: Basic plan with some actionable steps
3: Clear, actionable plan with defined milestones
4: Comprehensive, innovative plan with contingencies

Communication Skills

0: Not Enough Information Gathered to Evaluate
1: Struggles to articulate ideas clearly
2: Communicates ideas adequately
3: Articulates ideas clearly and engagingly
4: Exceptional communication with executive-level polish

Goal: Implement a customer health scoring system with 90% accuracy in predicting churn risk

0: Not Enough Information Gathered to Evaluate
1: Unlikely to Achieve Goal
2: Likely to Partially Achieve Goal
3: Likely to Achieve Goal
4: Likely to Exceed Goal

Goal: Achieve a Customer Satisfaction (CSAT) score of 95% or higher

0: Not Enough Information Gathered to Evaluate
1: Unlikely to Achieve Goal
2: Likely to Partially Achieve Goal
3: Likely to Achieve Goal
4: Likely to Exceed Goal

Overall Recommendation

1: Strong No Hire
2: No Hire
3: Hire
4: Strong Hire

Hiring Manager Interview

Directions for the Interviewer

This interview focuses on the candidate's relevant work history and performance. Ask the following questions for each relevant previous role, adapting as needed for time and the number of relevant roles. Ask all questions on the most recent or most relevant role. Probe for specific examples and quantifiable results. Pay attention to the progression of responsibilities and achievements across roles.

Directions to Share with Candidate

"I'd like to discuss your relevant work experience in more detail. We'll go through each of your previous roles, focusing on your responsibilities, achievements, and lessons learned. Please provide specific examples and metrics where possible."

Interview Questions

What were your main responsibilities in this role?

Guidance for Interviewer:Areas to Cover:

Scope of leadership role
Team structure and size
Key performance metrics and goals

Possible Follow-up Questions:

How did your responsibilities evolve over time?
What was the most challenging aspect of the role?
How did this role prepare you for your next career step?

What were your key performance metrics and how did you perform against them?

Guidance for Interviewer:Areas to Cover:

Specific NRR, churn, and CSAT targets
Performance relative to peers
Consistency of achievement

Possible Follow-up Questions:

What strategies did you use to consistently meet/exceed your targets?
How did you recover from any periods of underperformance?
What tools or resources were most helpful in tracking and improving your performance?

Tell me about your most significant customer success achievement in this role.

Guidance for Interviewer:Areas to Cover:

Nature of the achievement
Strategies implemented
Quantifiable results
Impact on the business

Possible Follow-up Questions:

What was your specific role in driving this achievement?
How did you overcome any obstacles?
What lessons from this achievement have you applied to subsequent roles?

Describe a time when you had to lead a major change initiative in your customer success organization. What happened and what did you learn?

Guidance for Interviewer:Areas to Cover:

Nature of the change initiative
Change management approach
Challenges faced and overcome
Results and lessons learned

Possible Follow-up Questions:

How did you gain buy-in from your team and other stakeholders?
What specific changes did you make to your approach based on this experience?
How have you applied these lessons in subsequent change initiatives?

Interview Scorecard

Leadership Experience

0: Not Enough Information Gathered to Evaluate
1: Limited leadership experience in customer success
2: Some leadership experience, but not at the scale required
3: Strong leadership experience aligned with role requirements
4: Extensive leadership experience exceeding role requirements

Performance History

0: Not Enough Information Gathered to Evaluate
1: Consistently underperformed against targets
2: Occasionally met targets with inconsistent performance
3: Consistently met or exceeded key performance metrics
4: Consistently top performer, significantly exceeding targets

Strategic Impact

0: Not Enough Information Gathered to Evaluate
1: Limited evidence of strategic contributions
2: Some strategic initiatives with moderate impact
3: Clear record of impactful strategic initiatives
4: Exceptional strategic contributions with organization-wide impact

Change Management

0: Not Enough Information Gathered to Evaluate
1: Struggles to lead change effectively
2: Basic change management skills
3: Strong change management capabilities with proven results
4: Exceptional change leader with innovative approaches

Goal: Increase overall Net Revenue Retention (NRR) to 120% within the first year

0: Not Enough Information Gathered to Evaluate
1: Unlikely to Achieve Goal
2: Likely to Partially Achieve Goal
3: Likely to Achieve Goal
4: Likely to Exceed Goal

Goal: Develop and launch two new customer success programs that demonstrably increase product adoption

0: Not Enough Information Gathered to Evaluate
1: Unlikely to Achieve Goal
2: Likely to Partially Achieve Goal
3: Likely to Achieve Goal
4: Likely to Exceed Goal

Overall Recommendation

1: Strong No Hire
2: No Hire
3: Hire
4: Strong Hire

Behavioral Competency Interview

Directions for the Interviewer

This interview assesses the candidate's behavioral competencies critical for success in the Senior Director of Customer Success role. Ask all candidates the same questions, probing for specific examples and details about the situation, actions taken, results achieved, and lessons learned. Avoid hypothetical scenarios and focus on past experiences.

Directions to Share with Candidate

"I'll be asking you about specific experiences from your past that relate to key competencies for this role. Please provide detailed examples, including the situation, your actions, the outcomes, and what you learned. Take a moment to think before answering if needed."

Interview Questions

Tell me about a time when you had to develop and implement a strategic initiative to improve customer outcomes across your entire customer base. (Strategic Thinking, Customer Centricity)

Guidance for Interviewer:Areas to Cover:

Process for identifying the strategic opportunity
Approach to developing the initiative
Implementation challenges and how they were overcome
Measurable impact on customer outcomes

Possible Follow-up Questions:

How did you gain buy-in from leadership and other departments?
What data did you use to inform your strategy?
How did you measure the success of this initiative?

Describe a situation where you had to lead a cross-functional team to resolve a complex customer issue or improve a critical customer journey. (Cross-functional Leadership, Change Management)

Guidance for Interviewer:Areas to Cover:

Nature of the issue or improvement opportunity
Composition of the cross-functional team
Leadership approach and challenges faced
Resolution process and outcome

Possible Follow-up Questions:

How did you align different departmental priorities?
What obstacles did you encounter and how did you overcome them?
How did you ensure the solution was sustainable long-term?

Give me an example of how you've used data analysis to uncover a significant opportunity for improving customer success operations or outcomes. (Data-driven Decision Making, Strategic Thinking)

Guidance for Interviewer:Areas to Cover:

Data sources and analysis process
Key insights uncovered
How insights were translated into action
Results achieved

Possible Follow-up Questions:

What tools or techniques did you use for your analysis?
How did you communicate your findings to leadership and your team?
Were there any surprises in the data, and how did you handle them?

Interview Scorecard

Strategic Thinking

0: Not Enough Information Gathered to Evaluate
1: Focuses primarily on tactical execution
2: Demonstrates some strategic planning abilities
3: Develops comprehensive, effective strategies
4: Creates innovative, market-leading strategic approaches

Customer Centricity

0: Not Enough Information Gathered to Evaluate
1: Limited focus on customer needs or outcomes
2: Basic consideration of customer needs in decision-making
3: Consistently prioritizes customer outcomes in strategies and decisions
4: Demonstrates exceptional understanding of customer needs, driving innovative solutions

Cross-functional Leadership

0: Not Enough Information Gathered to Evaluate
1: Struggles to work effectively across departments
2: Can collaborate with other departments but not lead effectively
3: Successfully leads cross-functional initiatives
4: Exceptional at driving collaboration and results across the organization

Change Management

0: Not Enough Information Gathered to Evaluate
1: Resistant to change or ineffective at leading change
2: Can implement changes when given clear direction
3: Effectively leads change initiatives with good results
4: Drives transformational change with exceptional results

Data-driven Decision Making

0: Not Enough Information Gathered to Evaluate
1: Relies primarily on intuition rather than data
2: Uses data but struggles to draw meaningful insights
3: Effectively uses data to drive decisions and improve outcomes
4: Sophisticated use of data analytics to drive strategic decisions

Goal: Increase overall Net Revenue Retention (NRR) to 120% within the first year

0: Not Enough Information Gathered to Evaluate
1: Unlikely to Achieve Goal
2: Likely to Partially Achieve Goal
3: Likely to Achieve Goal
4: Likely to Exceed Goal

Goal: Implement a customer health scoring system with 90% accuracy in predicting churn risk

0: Not Enough Information Gathered to Evaluate
1: Unlikely to Achieve Goal
2: Likely to Partially Achieve Goal
3: Likely to Achieve Goal
4: Likely to Exceed Goal

Overall Recommendation

1: Strong No Hire
2: No Hire
3: Hire
4: Strong Hire

Skip Level Behavioral Interview

Directions for the Interviewer

This interview further assesses the candidate's behavioral competencies from a different perspective. Ask all candidates the same questions, probing for specific examples and details about the situation, actions taken, results achieved, and lessons learned. Avoid hypothetical scenarios and focus on past experiences.

Directions to Share with Candidate

Interview Questions

Tell me about a time when you had to influence C-level executives to secure resources or support for a major customer success initiative. (Strategic Thinking, Influence)

Guidance for Interviewer:Areas to Cover:

Nature of the initiative and resources needed
Approach to building the business case
Strategies used to influence executives
Outcome and impact of the initiative

Possible Follow-up Questions:

How did you tailor your message for different executives?
What objections did you face and how did you overcome them?
How did you measure and communicate the ROI of this initiative?

Describe a situation where you had to balance the needs of customers with the strategic goals of the company. How did you approach this challenge? (Customer Centricity, Strategic Thinking)

Guidance for Interviewer:Areas to Cover:

Nature of the conflicting needs
Process for evaluating options
Decision-making approach
Communication with stakeholders
Outcome and lessons learned

Possible Follow-up Questions:

How did you gather input from different stakeholders?
What data did you use to inform your decision?
How did you handle any pushback or disappointment from either side?

Give me an example of how you've built and developed a high-performing customer success team. What strategies did you use, and what were the results? (Leadership, Team Development)

Guidance for Interviewer:Areas to Cover:

Team composition and size
Specific development strategies implemented
Performance management approach
Measurable improvements in team performance

Possible Follow-up Questions:

How did you identify and nurture top talent within your team?
What challenges did you face in building the team, and how did you overcome them?
How did you measure the impact of your team development efforts on customer outcomes?

Interview Scorecard

Strategic Thinking

0: Not Enough Information Gathered to Evaluate
1: Focuses primarily on short-term, tactical execution
2: Demonstrates some longer-term planning
3: Develops comprehensive strategies aligned with business goals
4: Creates innovative, market-leading strategic approaches

Influence

0: Not Enough Information Gathered to Evaluate
1: Struggles to persuade or influence others
2: Can influence peers but limited success with executives
3: Effectively influences stakeholders at all levels
4: Exceptional ability to influence and drive consensus at the highest levels

Customer Centricity

0: Not Enough Information Gathered to Evaluate
1: Limited focus on customer needs
2: Considers customer needs but struggles to balance with business goals
3: Effectively balances customer needs with strategic business objectives
4: Innovatively aligns customer success with business strategy, creating win-win scenarios

Leadership

0: Not Enough Information Gathered to Evaluate
1: Struggles to effectively lead teams
2: Basic leadership skills with room for improvement
3: Strong leader who develops effective teams
4: Exceptional leader who inspires and drives outstanding team performance

Team Development

0: Not Enough Information Gathered to Evaluate
1: Limited focus on team development
2: Basic approach to team development
3: Consistently develops high-performing teams
4: Innovative approach to team development with exceptional results

Goal: Reduce customer churn rate by 25% through improved onboarding and adoption processes

0: Not Enough Information Gathered to Evaluate
1: Unlikely to Achieve Goal
2: Likely to Partially Achieve Goal
3: Likely to Achieve Goal
4: Likely to Exceed Goal

Goal: Achieve a Customer Satisfaction (CSAT) score of 95% or higher

0: Not Enough Information Gathered to Evaluate
1: Unlikely to Achieve Goal
2: Likely to Partially Achieve Goal
3: Likely to Achieve Goal
4: Likely to Exceed Goal

Overall Recommendation

1: Strong No Hire
2: No Hire
3: Hire
4: Strong Hire

Debrief Meeting

Directions for Conducting the Debrief Meeting

The Debrief Meeting is an open discussion for the hiring team members to share the information learned during the candidate interviews. Use the questions below to guide the discussion.

Start the meeting by reviewing the requirements for the Senior Director of Customer Success role and the key competencies and goals to succeed.

The meeting leader should strive to create an environment where it is okay to express opinions about the candidate that differ from the consensus or the leadership's opinions.

Scores and interview notes are important data points but should not be the sole factor in making the final decision.

Any hiring team member should feel free to change their recommendation as they learn new information and reflect on what they've learned.

Debrief Meeting Questions

Does anyone have any questions for the other interviewers about the candidate?

Guidance: The meeting facilitator should initially present themselves as neutral and try not to sway the conversation before others have a chance to speak up.

Are there any additional comments about the Candidate?

Guidance: This is an opportunity for all the interviewers to share anything they learned that is important for the other interviewers to know.

How well does the candidate's experience align with our needs for driving customer success and increasing Net Revenue Retention?

Guidance: Discuss specific examples from the candidate's background that demonstrate their ability to achieve our NRR goals and improve customer outcomes.

What are your thoughts on the candidate's ability to implement and optimize our customer success technologies?

Guidance: Consider the candidate's experience with relevant tools and their track record of leveraging technology to improve customer success operations.

Is there anything further we need to investigate before making a decision?

Guidance: Based on this discussion, you may decide to probe further on certain issues with the candidate or explore specific issues in the reference calls.

Has anyone changed their hire/no-hire recommendation?

Guidance: This is an opportunity for the interviewers to change their recommendation from the new information they learned in this meeting.

If the consensus is no hire, should the candidate be considered for other roles? If so, what roles?

Guidance: Discuss whether engaging with the candidate about a different role would be worthwhile.

What are the next steps?

Guidance: If there is no consensus, follow the process for that situation (e.g., it is the hiring manager's decision). Further investigation may be needed before making the decision. If there is a consensus on hiring, reference checks could be the next step.

Reference Checks

Directions for Conducting Reference Checks

When conducting reference checks, remember that past performance is a strong indicator of future success. Select references carefully and ask the candidate to set up the calls. Use high-quality questions and follow-up probes to make the checks more predictive.

Be aware that it's tempting to overlook red flags in reference checks because it's the final stage. Don't just use it to reinforce beliefs formed about the candidate along the way.

Reference Check Questions

In what capacity did you work with [Candidate], and for how long?

Guidance: Establish the context of the relationship and the reference's ability to speak to the candidate's performance.

Follow-up: How closely did you work together on customer success initiatives?

How would you rate [Candidate]'s overall performance in their customer success leadership role?

Guidance: Use a scale of 1-10 to get a quantifiable measure, then probe for specifics.

Follow-up: What specific achievements or challenges led you to give that rating?

Can you describe [Candidate]'s approach to developing and implementing customer success strategies? What were the results?

Guidance: Look for evidence of strategic thinking and the ability to drive measurable outcomes.

Follow-up: How did these strategies impact customer retention and revenue growth?

How effective was [Candidate] at leading and developing their team?

Guidance: Probe for specific examples of team development and performance improvement.

Follow-up: Can you give an example of how they handled a challenging team situation?

What were [Candidate]'s key strengths in their role? Are there any areas where you think they need further development?

Guidance: Listen for alignment with the key competencies required for your role.

Follow-up: How do you think these strengths/development areas would impact their performance in our Senior Director of Customer Success role?

On a scale of 1-10, how likely would you be to hire [Candidate] again if you had an appropriate role available? Why?

Guidance: This question often elicits more candid feedback. Pay attention to both the score and the reasoning.

Follow-up: What kind of role do you think would be the best fit for [Candidate]'s skills and experience?

Is there anything else you think we should know about [Candidate] as we consider them for this senior leadership role in customer success?

Guidance: This open-ended question can sometimes reveal important information not covered by other questions.

Reference Check Scorecard

Overall Performance

0: Not Enough Information Gathered to Evaluate
1: Consistently underperformed expectations
2: Sometimes met expectations but inconsistent
3: Consistently met expectations
4: Consistently exceeded expectations

Strategic Thinking and Execution

0: Not Enough Information Gathered to Evaluate
1: Limited strategic capability, primarily tactical
2: Demonstrates some strategic thinking but struggles with execution
3: Develops and executes effective strategies
4: Exceptional strategic thinker with outstanding execution

Leadership and Team Development

0: Not Enough Information Gathered to Evaluate
1: Ineffective leader, team performance suffered
2: Adequate leader but limited team development
3: Effective leader who develops strong teams
4: Exceptional leader who builds and inspires high-performing teams

Customer Success Impact

0: Not Enough Information Gathered to Evaluate
1: Limited impact on customer success metrics
2: Some positive impact but below expectations
3: Significant positive impact on key customer success metrics
4: Transformative impact on customer success and business outcomes

Likelihood of Rehire

0: Not Enough Information Gathered to Evaluate
1: Would not rehire (1-3 on scale)
2: Might rehire with reservations (4-6 on scale)
3: Would likely rehire (7-8 on scale)
4: Would definitely rehire (9-10 on scale)

FAQ

Q: How long should each interview typically last?

A: The screening interview should take about 30 minutes. The work sample presentation should be 20 minutes with 10 minutes for Q&A. The hiring manager and behavioral competency interviews should each last approximately 45-60 minutes. Plan for about 3-4 hours total interview time across all stages.

Q: What if a candidate doesn't have experience with all the technologies mentioned?

A: Focus on the candidate's ability to learn and adapt quickly. Look for transferable skills and experience with similar technologies. You can find additional questions about adaptability and learning agility in our interview questions library.

Q: How should we handle candidates who struggle with the work sample exercise?

A: Consider giving candidates a second chance if they show promise in other areas. Sometimes nerves or misunderstanding of instructions can impact performance. You might offer a brief follow-up task or ask them to explain their thought process. For more insights on evaluating work samples, check out our blog post on structured interviewing.

Q: What if we can't gather enough information on a particular competency during the interview?

A: If you're unable to gather sufficient information on a key competency, consider adding a focused question in a follow-up interview. You can find additional competency-based questions in our comprehensive list of interview questions.

Q: How do we ensure consistency across different interviewers?

A: Conduct a thorough briefing with all interviewers before starting the process. Encourage them to stick to the provided questions and scoring criteria. Regular calibration sessions can help maintain consistency. For more tips, read our blog post on conducting effective interviews.

Q: What if a candidate's responses are too general or vague?

A: Use the provided follow-up questions to probe for more specific details. Ask for concrete examples and outcomes. Don't hesitate to politely interrupt and redirect if a candidate is going off-track. Our guide on asking the right questions can provide additional techniques.

Q: How should we handle disagreements among interviewers during the debrief?

A: Encourage open discussion and focus on specific observations rather than general impressions. Use the scorecard data as a starting point for discussion. If disagreements persist, consider conducting additional reference checks or a follow-up interview focused on the areas of concern. Our blog post on candidate debriefs offers more insights.

Q: What if a candidate doesn't meet all the listed qualifications but shows strong potential?

A: Focus on the candidate's core competencies, adaptability, and growth potential. Consider whether their strengths in certain areas might compensate for gaps in others. Discuss with the hiring team whether additional training could bridge any gaps. Our article on hiring for potential provides more guidance on this topic.

Was this interview guide helpful? You can build, edit, and use interview guides like this with your hiring team with Yardstick. Sign up for Yardstick and get started for free.